Friday, January 13, 2017

Jan 9 - Women, Economics, and Insurance


Jan 9 - Women, Economics, and Insurance
 
  • Why is our insurance employer-based?
  • Does that serve as a disadvantage to women in our society?
  • What about hair dressers or women working less than 30 hours a week? If the ACA goes away, what will be implications?
  •  http://aspe.hhs.gov/POVERTY/ Link to the Poverty guidelines
  • Were you aware there is a gender gap in salaries not only between waitresses and construction workers but between male and female physicians and lawyers?
  • How can it be addressed?
  • Your thoughts? http://www.bls.gov/
  • I suggest you explore the Bureau of Labor Statistics - it is an interesting site.

19 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have been aware of the pay gap for a while, but my proposed solution to the problem was recently proved to be unsuccessful, at least in one study.

    https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/07/business/research-suggests-women-are-asking-for-raises-but-men-get-them-more.html

    This article mentions an Australian study in which women and men ask for raises and equal amount of times, but men still get raises or greater raise percentages more often. My idea had always been, we need to stand up for ourselves and ask because we are typically known to be less confrontational. Ask and you shall recieve, right? Not really.

    I would like to see a similar study reproduced in the United States for more validity. Do American women hold themselves accountable the same way as Australian women? Are there more part-time or full-time women working and does that make a difference in asking for a raise?

    For now, I would still like to think that asking for a raise will yeild something in return, but maybe that is just naive of me.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I knew this election was going to have a serious impact on women's health, but I wanted to look further into how repealing the ACA would affect women's access to healthcare.
    If the ACA is repealed, over 55 million women will lose free access to no-copay birth control, mammograms, cervical cancer screenings, pap smears, bone density tests, screening for domestic violence, vaccines, STI testing, annual women's wellness exams, and other preventative care. The ACA made it so insurance companies were unable to charge women more than men for the exact same insurance plans or even just flat-out deny women health coverage just for being a women. Repealing the ACA would also mean that maternity coverage would no longer be considered an essential health benefit, leaving many women without the health coverage they need for a healthy pregnancy. In addition, insurers and employers would no longer be required to provide breastfeeding moms with necessary services and accommodations such as breast pumps, reasonable break times, and private spaces to pump.
    The ACA left out contraception of the legally mandated range of preventive services that insurers are required to provide due to protests and legal challenges of private businesses and religious organizations. Other providers such as Planned Parenthood provide reproductive and family planning services to clients. Yet, the House under GOP control has been strongly in favor of defunding Planned Parenthood which would eliminate access to contraception, prenatal care, sexual education, STD screening, cervical cancer screening, mammograms, and other preventative measures for low income women.
    By looking further into how the ACA has positively affected women's health, it is devastating that so many women could potentially lose their necessary health access without a replacement insurance plan.
    Side note: repealing the ACA would also mean that we don't get to stay on our parents' insurance plans until we are 26, which I'm sure would leave the majority of us uninsured.
    Some articles I read about the ACA/Planned Parenthood/etc.
    https://www.hhs.gov/healthcare/facts-and-features/fact-sheets/aca-working-women/index.html
    https://www.ndpha.org/resources/Pictures/1-10%20ACA%20Repeal%20Impacts%20on%20ND%20women.pdf
    http://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/opinion/readers/2017/01/13/aca-repeal-especially-hurt-women/96496854/
    http://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2017/01/15/509662288/that-vow-to-defund-planned-parenthood-easy-to-say-hard-to-do
    http://www.cnn.com/2015/08/04/health/planned-parenthood-by-the-numbers/
    http://money.cnn.com/2017/01/02/news/economy/repealing-obamacare-health-insurance/index.html

    ReplyDelete
  4. In reference to our discussion about the gender pay gap, we had talked about pharmacists being a profession where women made virtually equal pay to men. I found this article from CBS News in 2016 that lists pharmacists as #6 in their list of "11 professions with the biggest gender pay gaps." This article states that pharmacists who are women earn about 21.8% less than their male counterparts. It attributes this pay difference to the fact that men tend to take senior pharmacy roles which might correspond to higher pay. Other professions on the list included physicians, dentists, and computer programmers. I thought it was interesting. The information in the CBS article came from a study done by the employment site Glassdoor, and there is a link to the study in the article.
    http://www.cbsnews.com/media/11-professions-with-the-biggest-gender-pay-gaps/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I looked at the CBS article/data and they don't say if they controlled confounders like equal number of hours. Men are more likely to get promotions but if you compare staff pharmacist to staff pharmacist - the pay is close according to Bureau of Labor stats. I'll have to research more. Final line though - be aware of bias.

      Delete
  5. The gender pay gap seems to have been a hot topic to trend through news reports. I have always been aware that it exists, but would like to think that with higher education and time that gap closes. The Bureau of Labor Statistics has charts documenting wages, which shows that the gap remains parallel. Inflation has increased wages, but that gap has not made a considerable decrease in size between the wages of men and women. The data still reports a gap when dividing the wages among different education levels. What I also find interesting, is that studies have shown that women hold less “STEM” jobs than men. An analysis done on 2009 shows that women hold about 50% of total jobs, but less than 25% of science, technology, engineering, and math occupations (STEM). This study reported a 14 cent wage gap in STEM jobs between men and women; however, it found women make more in STEM jobs than other occupations. Women are not only making less, but they are also not holding the same jobs as men, which I found interesting through this one example.

    https://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2015/more-education-still-means-more-pay-in-2014.htm
    Beede, David N., et al. "Women in STEM: A gender gap to innovation." Economics and Statistics Administration Issue Brief 04-11 (2011).

    ReplyDelete
  6. I found an article called "The Simple Truth About the Gender Pay Gap" that I found particularly easy to read, straightforward, and very recent. I have listed the link here at the bottom on my comment. The article explains what the pay gap is and how it affects women. It breaks down how it affects women according to race/ethnicity, age, education level, and a few others. One of the more interesting (maybe because it related to me), is education and student debt. In the past, it would have been common to attribute the pay gap to education because, generally, men received a higher education than women. The more education, generally higher the earnings. But today, even with the same level of education, women's level of median earnings were less than men's. And now, across all racial and ethnic groups, American women now earn more college and post-graduate degrees than men. Discrimination appeared to be the reason for the pay gap in most of these situations. The pay gap then reflected in paying off student loans. Because women received lower earnings, they did not have as high of a percent of their student debt paid off as men in a set period of time after graduation. I had not thought about the effects of lower wage affecting debt, which would reflect credit and other areas of my life such as buying a home/renting an apartment, buying a car, etc. Thankfully we noted in class that the gap among pharmacists is less than other professions, but it is still a concern considering how much it will affect other parts of my life.

    http://www.aauw.org/aauw_check/pdf_download/show_pdf.php?file=The-Simple-Truth

    ReplyDelete
  7. I found an article that attempts to explain why the pay gap between men and women is smaller in pharmacy than it is in other occupations. The economist referenced in the article believes that the pay gap is not a matter of male vs female, education level, or leadership positions, but actually can be explained by the value of employees willing to work long hours and the nature of the position which “requires” this. In certain occupations (business and finance for example), an employer will reward employees who are willing to work extended hours during a week, which is typically males. To quote the article “the corporate world placed a huge premium on long hours—in other words, doubling our work week would far more than double your salary—and harshly penalized any time out of the labor force.” The reason that the author thinks that the pharmacist wage gap is smaller is that pharmacists are essentially interchangeable. Customers don’t care who is dispensing the medications as long as they are a professional so there is more room for part time work and a better home-work balance. This differs in other fields like law and finance where workers cannot be swapped as easily. This requirement in those positions is a disadvantage for women who are typically the ones who take care of children and the home at the expense of their career.

    http://www.slate.com/articles/business/moneybox/2014/03/closing_the_gender_wage_gap_what_pharmacies_can_teach_us.html

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Interesting article - the author adds a little snarky tone - "in the dimly lit area" but overall information in the article is good. Always wise to watch for bias and treatment

      Delete
  8. Well.. I have spent the last 20 min trying to figure out how to embed this video. But the link will have to do for now.

    https://youtu.be/13XU4fMlN3w

    This is a really neat video that does some research on where the pay gap comes from. They conclude that the biggest gap is when men and women are in their 20s-30s which is the typical age for women to start their families.

    If you go to the 4:10 mark, they specifically talk about pharmacists and why the wage gap is lower. According to their research, business careers have the biggest pay gap and it is due to the fact that they have a stricter schedule (usually 9-5). I really learned a lot from this video and think it would be beneficial for you to watch sometime.

    ReplyDelete
  9. http://www.insurancequotes.org/health-insurance/health-resources/coverage-for-women/

    This article explains women and health insurance coverage. It goes into some very interesting points explaining that some women have paid up to 63% more for the same coverage as men in private insurance plans. It also explains what women should do in certain situations such as losing their insurance. It also gives many health resources and education materials for women to use to be sure they are well educated on their health and their health insurance.

    ReplyDelete
  10. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Women are shown to earn less than men in almost all fields, even in fields that are typically dominated by females including teaching, nursing, and hairdressing, as proven by the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

    A study published by JAMA in July of 2016 too concluded that female physicians earn on average $20,000 less a year than their male counterparts. This study’s validity is bolstered as it adjusted for factors that determine compensation including age, experience, and specialty of practice. The study offers no reason for this absurd pay difference between the two sexes, but does refer to it as a complex “dilemma.” However, the study also states women are less likely to receive holiday bonuses and are less apt to negotiate their salaries with their employers unlike their male counterparts.

    It’s disappointing to see that women still earn much less than men in the medical field even though they have received equal schooling and training, and may also be better doctors or pharmacists than their male counterparts. If we cannot determine the root cause of this major pay difference, men will continue to earn more than women.

    (http://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/article-abstract/2532788)

    ReplyDelete
  12. Although the gender gap is beginning to close between men and women in our society, the "glass ceiling" is still present for women. Regardless of being a salary or hourly worker, men tend to get paid increasingly more than women in the same field of study. As a young professional, this information is discouraging and alarming to me, as I have put forth just as much effort to obtain this degree as my counterparts.

    In addition to the gender gap present in our society, insurance is a frustrating and difficult topic for everyone, as the policies are expensive and hard to understand for the general public. Without insurance, individuals face exponential costs for healthcare services. These alarming costs prevent individuals from seeking appropriate care to maintain a healthy lifestyle. According to a study done by the National Institute of Health in 2011, approximately 10% of women aged 18 to 64 did not obtain insurance coverage due to cost. For these individuals who are unable to obtain insurance through their employer, it is important for resources to be available to these citizen so they can have financial stability with healthcare services. As a pharmacist, I can be an advocate for federal and state funded resources to better serve the public health in our society.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  14. An important and relevant issue regarding women, economics, and insurance is the Affordable Care Act. Currently, under the ACA, birth control should be covered for all patients. With the new administration, it is difficult to know what changes will be made. Women are prescribed birth control for a variety of reasons, therefore, I do not understand the rationale behind pulling coverage of these products. It is also important to consider the consequences if Planned Parenthood is defunded. It would limit access to affordable care for women’s health. I am apprehensive about the consequences if various aspects involving women’s health are not covered or made difficult to access.

    Another note, I was unaware just how common the gender pay gap is among a wide variety of occupations. I do not believe it is fair to pay women less for the same work. The argument I tend to hear most often is that women of child-bearing age may take months off of work for maternity leave, leaving the place of employment in charge of finding a temporary replacement. I believe this is an unfair argument. Just because a women is of child-bearing age, does not mean she will be having children. In addition, women should not be discriminated against for starting a family. I honestly believe both men and women should be given time off when a baby is born to help spread the new responsibilities and give the dads time to bond with their newborn as well. I wonder how that would impact the gender pay gap.

    ReplyDelete
  15. While looking into the gender wage gap, I stumbled upon an interesting article written by CNN in March of 2016. I found this article to be quite different from many of the articles others have found. While the article states that there are multiple professions in which women are underpaid relative to men, it also states that there are some professions in which women earn more than their male counterparts. Such professions include social worker, merchandiser, research assistant, purchasing specialist, physician advisor, communications associate, social media salesperson, health educator, and procurement specialist. This data was determined based upon the job search site, Glassdoor, looking at salary reports of their users. This article somewhat stumped me, as I had never heard of women earning more than their male counterparts. However, upon further research, I realized that the original study used anonymous reports of salary, which I believe is not a reliable source of data. The original study also stated that they were unable to control for factors such as race/ethnicity, marital status, the presence of children, and innate worker ability. Thus, there is a good chance that this data may be incorrect.
    In reading through other’s comments, it seems as though there are discrepancies in reports of the wage gap. I think that it is absolutely critical to evaluate and analyze data regarding the wage gap so that we better understand where we, as women, stand in regard to wages. I believe that in order to address the wage gap, we need to fully grasp and understand the wage gap and the reasons for which it continues to occur.
    http://money.cnn.com/2016/03/23/pf/gender-pay-gap/
    https://research-content.glassdoor.com/app/uploads/sites/2/2016/03/Glassdoor-Gender-Pay-Gap-Study.pdf

    ReplyDelete