Our speakers were Barbara Hubbs a 70+ year old woman diagnosed with breast cancer. And Dr Enz who discussed dealing with BRCA1 gene and decisions involving her family and future.
- We discussed a number of issues related to the diagnosis of breast cancer from the view of a breast cancer survivor/champion.
- Was there enough new information here -- something that made you think?
- How do poor women get these expensive treatments?
- If an educator BS+MS gets confused with all the information -- how about someone with low health literacy?
- Have you heard of or discussed "chemo brain"?
- How best then to do patient education? Should everything be in written form for future reference?
- What questions remain? What thoughts do you want to share? How will you interact with these patients in a community pharmacy to let them know you are there to discuss issues with them?
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteSomething that stood out to me when listening to the speakers is that, when it comes to cancer, information is abundant, diverse, and usually confusing regardless of an individual’s intelligence. Health literacy is an issue in all areas of health, however people tend to have even lower health literacy regarding cancer. I think this leads cancer patients to simply listen to their doctors. Not to say this is a bad thing, but it may lend to patients not taking an active role in their treatment. I thought about this when Barbara’s doctor told her “71 is the new 51” when talking her into undergoing chemo. Although this phrase is amazing as an emotional appeal, Barbara’s treatment discussion seemed to be what her physician decided it would be. On the flip side, oncology treatment regimens are rigid depending on the cancer. Usually the options are complete surgery and chemo/radiation treatment or don’t. Regardless, having low health literacy must make the entire treatment process more intimidating for the patient. As pharmacists, I believe we can make a positive impact by asking open-ended questions and eliciting patient questions.
ReplyDeleteAlso, “chemo brain” was new information to me; I had never heard of it even though I’ve watched several family members undergo chemotherapy. With chemo brain, I think written patient education would be helpful, but I also believe this is yet another area of cancer care where caregivers are crucial.
In our society, breast cancer awareness is advocated for through various programs, events, and fundraisers. Even with all of the information available to the public, there are still many concerns that patients diagnosed with breast cancer will have throughout therapy. It was interesting to talk about the BRCA gene and how it is passed down and the options for breast cancer prevention. I had not heard of the BRCA gene until pharmacy school, so I am not sure that most patients would even know what questions to ask regarding testing for that. I wonder if in the future we will have more education provided regarding the BRCA gene.
ReplyDeleteIn terms of chemo brain, I was unaware that it could be an issue until this class. Now thinking about it, when my grandparents went through chemotherapy, I remember them talking about feeling “off” and not being able to function as well as they could before chemotherapy. I agree with Elizabeth that it would be helpful to have more education on this side effect and how caregivers can be of assistance.
My sister-in-law recently posted a video about her mother who is living with Stage 4 metastatic breast cancer. She discusses her therapy, the patient perspective, and how to stay positive throughout the process. It is an interesting video and I believe it related to the topic we were discussing this week. I have included the link at the bottom of my post.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RWlecTEBDAQ&feature=youtu.be
I think that cancer is a hard topic because it is so individualized. Regarding patient education, what materials should be presented depend. Each patient has an entirely different story it seems. There are patients that are completely blind-sided, patients who choose to ignore or find it had to accept their diagnosis, patients who take it head on. I think it is hard to present information on cancer simply because each patient will process it differenty. I think that some will want to know anything and everything they can and some want to know as little as possible. We have so much information, but do we want to give it all to our patients? I personally wouldn't want to be overloaded with information, but I would want to know the most important things. I think that patient education for such a heavy factor in people's lives should be available in multiple forms though - oral, written, easily accessible to be researched, and easily accessible providers of care.
ReplyDeleteI think no matter what type of cancer patient we see, there will be differences in care that need to be addressed. As healthcare providers, I think our most important role is to be supportive to patients and their families in providing access to information and help that they may need, understanding that that may look very varied for each patient.
As we discussed in class, the terminology and overall disease state is very confusing, even for the educated healthcare provider. I think most women only have the general understanding of breast cancer, such as looking for a lump in the breast. But like the video we watched in class about the inflammatory breast cancer demonstrated how little women know about breast cancer; I had never heard of inflammatory breast cancer before that video. I thought this video was a great representation of the education that needs to be given to the general population. I think there should be more news broadcasts, public service announcements on TV, and billboards to reach the majority of people. I also think that when women goes to the doctor for regular checkups, pamphlets should be passed out to women every time (not just offered, but given) about the importance of regular self-checks, mammograms, and signs and symptoms to look for in breast cancer.
ReplyDeleteI can imagine that these treatments are extremely expensive. I think it would be a financial burden for anyone having to receive these treatments. It must be incredibly difficult for poorer women to afford these treatments, and may even be a reason some women delay detection and treatment.
Before coming to class last week, I had never heard of the term chemo brain. After researching, I was disappointed by the amount of factual information that existed on this condition. The American Cancer Society defines chemo brain as a decrease in mental “sharpness”; being unable to remember certain things and having trouble finishing tasks or learning new skills. The American Cancer Society also recommends incorporating simple tools to help manage this mental decline that may offer some help. The society recommends using a daily planer, maintaining a consistent sleep schedule, getting regular physical exercise and eating vegetables. There are no preventative measures put forth by the organization. The lack of preventative measures available and the miniscule amount of things that can be done to manage the condition would frighten me as a chemotherapy patient. The fact that the cancer is already causing pain and the mental decline would compound the problems. The condition and the treatment effects sound unbearable.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.cancer.org/treatment/treatments-and-side-effects/physical-side-effects/changes-in-mood-or-thinking/chemo-brain.html
My paternal grandmother had breast cancer and before this class and therapeutics this semester I never thought much about asking her more about what her therapy entailed.The only information I know about her therapy was that she had a mastectomy of one breast and the took out her axillary lymph nodes on the same side. She is now 93 and has been cancer free without any further issues. But hearing the two stories that were shared in class, I am going to try to be more aware of my body and the fact that I may have a higher chance of breast cancer.
ReplyDeleteBefore this class I had never heard of chemo brain, and feel that all patient education should be in written form as well as communicated to the family. My first rotation in may is oncology so I am glad to have learned more details about various cancers in this class.
It was helpful to hear about living with breast cancer and deciding treatment from a patient perspective and then compare it to the therapeutics knowledge we just learned. One of the side effects of chemotherapy that was not really mentioned in therapeutics, was chemo brain. I had heard of this term before but had never considered what it meant for the patient. As healthcare providers, we definitely need to be able to educate patient’s on this condition. It would be great if the doctor discussed treatment and side effects, and then sent home references that a patient could review. A pharmacist, could then reinforce the major points with their patients. I feel as if a lot of people go home and google search their diagnosis and every possible treatment out there—but this gets confusing to the patient. A community pharmacist should try to reach out each time the patient or caregiver is picking up medications and check in on their diagnosis and treatment, just to see if there are still any unanswered questions.
ReplyDeleteAdditionally, I was glad we covered inflammatory breast cancer and watched the video on this type of cancer because I had never heard of it previously. There are so many support groups and organizations that advocate for breast cancer; however, most stress about doing self-examinations and checking for lumps. I already get questions from family members about health-related topics, so this will be extremely important information to at least be aware of.
I thought it was very helpful to briefly discuss inflammatory breast cancer because I really had no knowledge of it prior to our class discussion, and I'm sure many of our patients don't have a lot of knowledge (or any at all) on it either. It really struck me when that woman in the video we watched spent her days spreading awareness to women about inflammatory breast cancer and how she just wished she had known about it. I hate the idea that patients and their family members would feel that way about a disease state and that is why it is so important for us to be educated and continue to seek information about disease states we don't know as much about.
ReplyDeleteI also thought it was really powerful to hear from Dr. Enz about her experience and to hear about how this gene wasn't just impacting her, but now her children. It is hard to think about what I would do in a similar situation because, as she mentioned, her daughter has not yet had children and built her family, but is at increased risk. I think this really opened my eyes to the realities of breast cancer and the genetics involved. It definitely gave me a greater sense of empathy -- something I already thought I had for breast cancer patients.
It is hopeful to consider how far we have come in terms of treatment and technology to fight breast cancer. My grandmother and both of her sisters had breast cancer (my grandma being the only survivor) so this is definitely something that has impacted me personally and I would imagine will continue to impact my family in the future.
This topic has become all too real for me just in the past day. This morning, I (with my cousins) received a lengthy email from my aunt. The contents of the email explained that she received unfortunate results after a follow-up mammogram. She is going to have an active biopsy and lumpectomy in April. My aunt, like others we have heard from, thought it was no big deal and didn't want to worry anyone about it. It's such a scary thing to battle by yourself (physically and emotionally). I can't imagine what she has been going through just the past few weeks. She is well educated and is still extremely overwhelmed/somewhat confused with all of this new information.
ReplyDeleteI'm so relieved that there are support groups for patients like my aunt. I believe that not only the patients but their caregivers and the ones that interact daily with the patient should be counseled on patient education. I think it should also be written down, so the patient and/or caregivers can refer to it whenever necessary. Information can be extremely overwhelming at first and will (probably) need to be referenced later.
Dr. VanTyle made a great point last week. We need to give cancer patients encouragement. These patients go through a lot and even if we lift their spirits just a tad, it is so worth it! I've just always avoided the subject of cancer when talking with the patients affected. I didn't want to make them upset. But now I will do my best to make sure I am helping them in any way I can- even if it's just with a smile :)
Cancer is unfortunately all too familiar in many families. I am thankful for my education and that I can use it to help families cope with the disease state and fight it.
thanks - encouragement goes a long way and we need to learn to communicate with patients and not avoid sticky situations. Best wishes for your aunt. Now maybe you can combine your brain knowledge and your heart to help translate medical terms and also encourage you aunt as she travels the next few months.
DeleteI thought that I knew a lot about breast cancer because we learn about it a few times throughout our pharmacy curriculum, but I was wrong. There is so much information out there that I doubt that I could ever feel like I know it all. Hearing more about the BRCA1 gene was interesting. I had never really thought about male relatives as being affected by it. I knew they could be carriers, but I wasn't aware that it also increases their risk of breast cancer. I feel like being tested for the gene is beneficial if you know you have a family history of it. Knowing what we know now, being aware of the gene could help motivate patients to stay on top of preventative care as well as help them to catch problem spots early. I have empathy for Dr. Enz and others in her position who have children and what their options will be if they find out they are also affected by the mutation.
ReplyDeleteI was also interested to hear about chemo brain, which I was unaware of before this discussion. It makes sense that these intense therapies can cause adverse memory effects. Now that I know that memory is affected, I would say that written patient education could be the most beneficial. I feel that it is always vital to educate the patient verbally, but in the treatment setting it is easy to become overwhelmed so I feel like sending home a written summary would be very beneficial for review at a later time if the patient has trouble remembering everything that is discussed.
Our breast cancer discussion was beneficial and helped me to think about different aspects that I hadn't before. I also feel that hearing from two women with different breast cancer experiences was valuable as well and I appreciated both of their insight and comments on their experiences.
From the speakers, I learned something about the human side of this disease. What I mean by that is, they talked about the effect on their families and about how they had to make choices about whether or not to be treated when they were given the statistics that weren’t necessarily the greatest. Both speakers were very candid and spoke about the good and the bad from what has happened.
ReplyDeleteI have heard of “chemo brain”. It was a term mentioned to my aunt right after my uncle’s diagnosis of lung cancer. They made sure she knew what was going on and how to administer some of his at-home medications due to the fact that my uncle would possibly be unable to help her. I believe they also sent paperwork home with them, but I only got a glimpse of it once when my aunt let me see his chemo regimen. I think it is helpful to have the written source, just because not every chemo patient will have a good support system or may even have some instances where their caregiver is gone for a moment and cannot help them. It is very easy to get lost in a sea of medical terminology, especially upon diagnosis of cancer. Patient education and support is critical for the best outcomes in these patients.
We have a couple patients now in my pharmacy that are undergoing chemotherapy. I know for a fact my pharmacist makes sure to talk to them each time they come in just to see how things are going and ask about their family as well. It is the little things like that I think go a long way. Those patients know they can go to their pharmacist with any question, even during a time that seems overwhelming with information and medication.
I thought listening to Dr. Enz talk about her experience with preventative surgeries after discovering she was positive for the BRCA gene extremely interesting. I didn't have much knowledge about the BRCA gene to begin with, but I definitely didn't know you could undergo preventative surgery. I have a lot of empathy for Dr. Enz and other patients undergoing similar situations who not only have to worry about their own health, but their children's regarding whether or not they potentially have the mutation as well and what steps are appropriate to take if they discover that they are positive for the mutation. I also found it interesting that her son could potentially carry the gene as well, you usually automatically associate the BRCA gene/breast cancer with women.
ReplyDeleteI had never heard of inflammatory breast cancer before. I found it interesting that when the woman called 4 cancer centers asking about inflammatory breast cancer, only 1 knew anything about it. I think it is important as a healthcare professional to know and recognize the symptoms of IBC (a swollen breast, a red rash, itching, a flattened nipple, stabbing pain, and orange-peel like texture) and spread the word, since so many people are unaware of this cancer and its severe consequences.
I definitely think it is important to have empathy for our cancer patients and be positive. There is already so much negativity and pain associated with cancer that it is our job to add some hope and positivity into their lives.
Hearing from both of the patients was useful in learning about different situations. Especially hearing from Dr. Enz made me think about the decisions patients may have to make. Hearing from both patients also helped me realize the significance of place in life in terms of decision making. Different age groups may be at different points in their life that affect how they chose to proceed after such a diagnosis or genetic knowledge.
ReplyDeleteCancer is a very difficult topic, even for educated healthcare professionals. Treatment is typically individualized based on the patient. For patients, it can be hard to understand all of the terms and abbreviations used. Most patients, especially those with low health literacy may have less knowledge of their diagnosis and treatment options.
Prior to this discussion, I had not heard of chemo brain. It is important for patients and caregivers/family members to understand this side effect.
I am glad we covered inflammatory breast cancer because I had never heard of it. I think many people associate lumps with breast cancer and no one really talks about this type and its presentation. Women may delay going to their provider because they don't know how serious their symptoms can be. It is disheartening to know that many of these diagnosed are advanced and have a poor prognosis.
I think education with both conversation with patients and caregivers as well as provide written material for reference. I think it is also important to make time throughout the treatment process to talk with the patient and answer any questions rather than just initial counseling. In the midst of such a significant diagnosis, patients will probably not know all the questions they want to ask. I also think that pharmacists can play a crucial role as a supportive healthcare provider throughout treatment. Pharmacists can answer patient questions and offer them support as they go through treatment.
I think it was very beneficial to hear these two women tell us about their experience with breast cancer. We learn about breast cancer, but it is hard to really grasp the impact of the disease on a patient’s overall health unless you hear it from them. Barbara talked about how she didn’t want to go through with the chemotherapy initially even though she knew that it could lengthen her life. Dr. Enz talked about knowing she had the gene and then the decisions she had to make and now they have to decide if her children should be tested. I think that would be extremely difficult and then if they are positive, deciding what the next step would be. I tried to think about what I would do if I was in that situation but I think it is impossible to really know until that is your reality. Both of the patients we heard from were able to give us a perspective of what they went through and the decisions they had to make. I think there is a lot of information about cancer that a patient can find that makes it extremely overwhelming, even to an educated patient. Someone with low health literacy would definitely have difficulty filtering through and understanding the information.
ReplyDeleteI had not heard about “chemo brain” prior to this discussion but I definitely think that could affect a patient’s outcomes. If they cannot remember the instructions they were given and how their medications should be taken, the efficacy could be affected. I think written patient education would be very beneficial in this instance to assist the patient and the caregiver. Even without chemo brain, I think that written patient education would be beneficial because patients and caregivers will be getting a lot of information during an emotional time so it would be difficult to remember everything and then having the worry of “am I doing this right?” In the pharmacy, I will support these patients by encouraging them and trying to answer questions they have.
In passing I had heard of chemo brain but I had not seen anything solid about it. I think written information would be a good choice, or online videos or recordings for patients to come back to. If nothing else, we can make sure they have our contact information and do our best to make them feel comfortable calling us for concerns.
ReplyDeleteI do worry how poor women will get these expensive treatments. As the ACA is replaced and changes to Medicaid and Medicare are made, I worry about them not being able to get screenings or treatment. Not to mention that with the proposed bill H.R.354 — 115th Congress (2017-2018) (link at the bottom). There are a lot of women who rely on PP for breast exams and referrals for mammograms. Their 2014-2015 annual report states that there was ‘271,539 Pap tests performed, 363,803 breast exams performed, 71,717 women whose cancer was detected early or whose abnormalities were identified’ that year.’ Are there ways for pharmacists to also help provide breast exams if worse comes to worse and they are no longer available through PP?
https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/house-bill/354
https://www.plannedparenthood.org/files/2114/5089/0863/2014-2015_PPFA_Annual_Report_.pdf
This discussion on breast cancer brought was very informative. I had heard of the BRCA mutation some before, mostly from the media and Angelina Jolie’s health issues, but thought it was fascinating to hear from Dr. Enz and how brave of a decision she made when she had her genetic results back. I can imagine how difficult it would be for women with less education or lower socioeconomic status to get the preventive treatment they may need or could be helpful for them. I also found it interesting how Barbara mentioned she really didn’t speak to the pharmacist about her chemo or barely was told about any of them. I am sure it is up to the patient individually if they even want to be aware of the effects, etc. but I think that would be an important role for a pharmacist who has specific training in the area of chemo to be as informative as possible for patients.
ReplyDeleteThe discussion last Monday brought to my attention Inflammatory Breast Cancer, which is something I have never heard of before. I was shocked to hear the statistics on it and still amazed that I had never heard of it. Its presentation really surprised me in that it seems like something everyone may experience every now and then (something appears to be a bug bite) but could end up being so detrimental. I think more education on topics like those would be great because those are possible to be caught by the patient herself and could really save a life if caught soon enough.
I'm very glad that we took the time to discuss inflammatory breast cancer in class. While my mom and other family members have gone through breast cancer scares, I had never heard of this specific type of breast cancer until we watched the news excerpt in class. One would never know that this type of cancer, strangely enough, feels and looks like more of a bug bite and is hot to the touch. I would never imagine that this type of cancer is much more deadly that of regular hormone responsive/non-responsive breast cancer.
ReplyDeleteIt was also necessary to hear from our guest speaker that she experienced chemo-brain while undergoing treatment. Since none of my immediate family members have gone through chemotherapy, I was not aware of chemo-brain. Patients definitely need to be educated about this unfortunate side effect, and health care providers need more adequate training in reference to this adverse effect.
I have learned a few times in my life that what doesn't kill you makes you stronger and I feel like my experience with breast cancer, multiple surgeries, and facing what lies ahead for me and my family has made me a better mom, wife, friend and mentor. I appreciate every day. I have enjoyed getting to know all of you and wish you all the best! Dr. Enz
ReplyDeleteOne thing that I think most about cancer is how it dramatically impacts not only the person who has the condition, but the rest of the persons family. This was seen when Dr. Enz talked about being positive for the BRCA1 mutation. Although she does not have cancer at this time, she has to constantly be worried about the cancer of getting it and also is worried about passing the gene off to her kids. Unlike other ways off dying such as a heart attack, cancer can slowly kill your love one and sometimes all you can do is sit and watch as your love one slowly deteriorates.
ReplyDeleteEven with the potential cure for some types of cancers, the person doesn't always recover fully to be the exact same as they once were. This is caused by chemo brain which makes it harder for people to remember things that they once could. This could make it harder for doctors/pharmacists in terms of patient education to that patient. Ways in order to combat this problem could be to notify caregivers of the patient as well as write down all of the patient education for the patient so that they can refer to the information when they have forgotten what to do. Overall, cancer is a very scary condition that have taken so many love ones from people over the years and should be something that everyone should take seriously.
Cancer is a word that one hopes to never hear, as there are many negative connotations and outcomes associated with this term. Even though I am on my way to becoming a healthcare professional, I find myself confused and frustrated when learning and reading about the various forms of cancer, as many drug names and treatment options are difficult to pronounce and understand. As an educated individual, I become concerned with individuals who have a low literacy rate. Each and every patient has a right to understand the information provided, as their life becomes dependent upon it. Aside from our discussion in class, I was not aware with the term "chemo brain". Providing information and resources in a patient-friendly manner will allow individuals to be an advocate for their own health and treatment. In addition to the difficult information to understand, the cost of treatment is substantial. I have a hard time contemplating or imagining the financial obligations that are associated with the treatment, in which I will make a conscious effort to show empathy to each of my patients.
ReplyDeletePrior to coming to class, I did know quite a bit of information on the topic of breast cancer. My mom was diagnosed with Ductal Carcinoma in Situ in 2008. Even though I didn’t fully understand everything at the time, my mom was fairly open with me about her diagnosis and treatment. She had a mastectomy followed by 5 years of oral therapy with Femara (letrozole). She did not have the BRCA1 gene. I remember her having drainage tubes in place after her mastectomy and making the decision not to have reconstructive surgery. I remember her telling me that she always felt a little foggy while taking the Femara. While I do not know the cost of the mastectomy, I do know that she had good insurance and that her medication cost approximately $300 per year for 5 years in total. I can only imagine what it would be like for someone in poverty or someone who does not have insurance to attempt to receive and pay for these treatments. Even though I knew all of this through my mother, I still found it very interesting to listen to the stories of Barbara Hubbs and Dr. Enz. Additionally, I thought that it was very interesting learning about inflammatory breast cancer, as I had never really heard about this type of breast cancer before.
ReplyDeleteIn regard to “chemo brain,” I had heard of the term before. I believe that I heard this term because my brother had medulloblastoma, a type of brain tumor, and often experienced “chemo brain.” However, after reading through other’s comments, I did not know that many people had not heard of the term. For this reason, I think that it is important to have further education on chemotherapy and its side effects for the benefit of healthcare professionals.