Wednesday, April 19, 2017

April 3: Patient perspective on Assisted reproduction

What are your thoughts and comments?

15 comments:

  1. I have never personally known anyone who has needed to use assisted reproduction but I had heard a lot about it before this class on TV as well as hearing about certain celebrities that went through the assisted reproduction process. When Dr.Smith came and talked to us I was surprised by the negative stigma that she said surrounded the topic. I myself have never thought of this as something that should not be utilized by families if it will help them with being happy and having children. Her story really helped me understand how much patients go through in order to have children, and the struggles women face when deciding what to do with all of the embryos. I feel much more ready to talk to patients about this topic and hope that I can offer some help and guidance to those patients who need it! I believe that this will become much more prevalent in years to come and look forward to giving people resources to help them in their journey of building a family.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think that assisted reproduction is a wonderful advance in technology and healthcare. Although (as we learned from Meghan’s presentation about ART and religions) there are some religions that do not agree with their use.

    I would consider myself a pretty religious person and have a strong sense of God’s presence in my life. I believe much of this is due to how I was raised. I have some difficulty with various religions’ views on ART. I do not believe that “God made a couple infertile for a reason.” It seems that numerous religions do not support the use of assisted reproduction because it works against God and the natural process of the formation of life. However, I know numerous families, and even my own parents, who have gone through these assisted reproductive processes. I personally believe that it is the couple’s choice, given that they cannot conceive naturally or have trouble conceiving naturally, what the best option is for having a family, if they so desire a family (such as adoption, assisted reproductive means, or other).

    I appreciated that Dr. Smith told the class her choices when she was told she could not conceive naturally. It is an important point to bring up that not all people are willing to adopt based on past experiences or their own beliefs. Before Dr. Smith talked to our class and expressed the social stigma surrounding assisted reproductive therapies, specifically surrounding IVF, I was unaware of such thoughts. This may be due to the people in my life and their past experience and/or current experience with assisted reproduction. When I practice pharmacy in the future (likely in the community setting), I will be very supportive of couples who come to pick up these types of therapies. I also plan to be a helpful source and informed perspective on the different reproductive assistance choices for my family and friends.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hearing from Dr. Smith was a beneficial experience since I knew very little about IVF prior to this class. I appreciated her clearly stating that women with ovulatory disorders can utilize medications whereas those with anatomical disorders require other procedures for reproductive assistance. Listening to her discuss an IVF cycle was highly involved; after reflecting on the topic, I don’t think I could do it. It just sounds like too much! Understanding the medication regimen further highlights what women go through, both the emotional and physical demands, regardless of whether a successful pregnancy is achieved. I was sad to hear from Dr. Smith that community pharmacists were the ‘worst’ healthcare professionals she interacted with during her IVF journey. This reiterates that pharmacists must approach every patient as a unique individual and that we must continue to educate ourselves.

    Dr. Smith mentioned NAPRO briefly. She said that this program looks for a root cause of infertility before families turn to IVF. I have personal experience with NAPRO (Natural Procreative) Technology: my sister and myself were part of the program for about a year each. Even though it may sound like an alternative treatment or some may think of it negatively due to its connection with Catholicism, I had a positive experience. I believe the program could be a potential first step for families experiencing infertility as they focus on looking at menstrual patterns via charting. It’s different than natural family planning. However, if a woman were to have an anatomical disorder, traditional infertility specialists would probably be necessary. My point: NAPRO is a legitimate option for women should they choose to seek alternative assistance.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think hearing a patient perspective on this topic was helpful and very interesting. I think that some of the negative feelings toward ART are counterproductive. This is a big decision for a family to make and one that they likely did not come to without extensive thought and consideration. Families are trying to do what they think is best for them so they should not be subject to negative thoughts from other people. For a family struggling with infertility, the ability to have a child should be a happy time for the family. They should not have to worry about judgment from other people for their choice to undergo ART or feel ashamed that they needed to go that route. Even after hearing about the religious views on ART, I still believe that it should be a family decision. Similar to birth control, I believe that there are numerous Catholics and Christians undergoing ART despite the official Church views. I think that ART is an excellent advancement in medicine that provides parents with family options they had not had in the past.

    ReplyDelete
  5. It was interesting to hear the story about ART from a patient's perspective. I think it gives students a better idea of the emotional journey that these people go through. The decisions that have to be made from the time of deciding to start the process, to how many cycles to buy, to how many eggs to implant can all be difficult and emotionally draining for patients. I can also appreciate that it could be very hard if things go wrong in delivery or the baby has developmental problems because you are responsible for trying so hard to bring this child into the world and now he/she will have difficulties for life.

    The discussion also makes you think about what you would do if you found yourself in a situation such as this. It is hard to consider how much you would do, how much you would pay, how long you would try to have a child. Especially at our age, it is hard to imagine ourselves in that position. I think that the decision about what avenues to explore and what types of therapy to pursue should be up to the family. The decision to go through with IVF is a very personal one and one that should receive support from the health care team. IVF is a huge medical advancement that can make a profound difference for a family.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I do not personally know anyone that has used assisted reproduction techniques, but it is something I was interested in learning more about. Infertility is an issue that affects a large number of women. I am sure most women do not foresee facing challenges when first trying to conceive. I can only imagine how these parents feel. I think it is important to know when to seek help from a specialist and the options that are available. I was unaware of the stigma associated with assisted reproduction. I did not consider that these parents may feel uncomfortable talking to their family members about the process or that they may worry about how or when to tell their children conceived by these methods. Empathy plays a huge role in working with patients who use assisted reproduction. Putting yourself in the shoes of these patients and considering the cost, energy, and time these couples invest in starting a family. It was beneficial to have Dr. Smith speak about her experience with assisted reproduction. Her story was insightful and shed light on the difficulties throughout the process of using assisted reproductive techniques.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I thought when Dr. Smith came in and talked about this issue, it was one of the most beneficial classes for me. I thought it was really important to get to hear about the emotional/challenging side of all of this, especially coming from someone who is a pharmacist as well as a patient in this circumstance. Dr. Smith talked about how after speaking publicly about reproductive therapy, she was approached by so many people who shared similar experiences. I think this is something we don't talk about a lot, but so many women are affected by it. Even if a lot of us don't know someone right now who has used assisted reproductive techniques, a lot of us probably will in our lifetime.
    Before our discussion in class and hearing from Dr. Smith, I had never considered the difficulties that may come along with deciding if and how and when to talk to your children about this. That would be a difficult decision, and I don't know how I would feel trying to discuss that with my child.
    I think the most important takeaway from all of this is that we need to have compassion and empathy for our patients and the difficult time they might be going through. Dr. Smith said that the pharmacist in her situation was not helpful and told her "don't get pregnant" on these medications, which could be especially troubling for a patient who isn't a healthcare professional. After hearing that, I knew I didn't want to be that person and I wanted to find a better way to approach these sorts of situations.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I thought it was really beneficial to have Dr. Smith come in to talk to us about her experience with infertility and assisted reproduction. I had no idea that there was such a stigma associated with assisted reproduction. I didn't realize how uncomfortable it might be to talk about with your family and friends, but it makes sense because it is such a sensitive subject. I thought it was interesting to listen to Dr. Smith talk about adoption. Most people would think that if you cannot conceive naturally, that the most logical next step would be to adopt, but it makes sense that if a woman has dreamed of giving birth to her own children, that she has the right to try everything she can to make that happen.

    I also found it interesting to listen to Dr. Smith talk about whether she has thought about how and when she will tell her daughter that she was conceived using assisted reproduction. I again had never thought of this as being an issue, but it makes sense that this would be a very difficult conversation to have with your child.
    I think this was an important topic to talk about so that we have more of an understanding and empathetic mindset when talking to women who are going through assisted reproduction treatments.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I am so glad that Dr. Smith came in and shared her journey about having her children. I have never known anyone personally who has had to go through ART, so hearing a firsthand encounter really helped to put it into perspective. I found it really interesting to hear the process of how she and her husband decided that adoption would not be best for them. I think in general when you hear of someone who can’t have a child, you automatically think adoption is the best idea. It really helped me to realize that this may not be the best option for individuals and how important it is to be more sensitive about the topic. I also am surprised to see such intricate schedules that these couples have to go to in order to have the timing right and as she mentioned, how much one may have to miss work or change her schedule around in order to make the appropriate times and appointments. After hearing her story, I hope I can be more of a resource and more understanding of families who are going through this and appreciate the extent to which families will go to in order to have a child of their own.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Like the other guest speakers, I enjoyed hearing about Dr. Smith’s experience with infertility and IVF. Her insight and patient perspective on the subject was very beneficial. It was shocking to hear that community pharmacists were not that helpful in her circumstances; yet, we don’t have very extensive coverage on the subjects in our curriculum. I don’t personally know anyone who has gone through this experience, so it was very interesting to learn more about the schedules, medications, and point-of-views on the process. I also hadn’t thought about what it would be like to tell your children about the IVF process or friends and family. In my opinion, it is just amazing that this technology even exists, so I forget that it can be controversial. Additionally, Meghan’s information on religion and ART was thought provoking. It can never hurt to at least have an understanding on the background of patient beliefs.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Dr. Smith’s experiences with having children really opened my eyes to a sensitive topic that many women deal with. I have a little experience with this subject, which came from a friend who despite being young and healthy was having trouble conceiving. She had always wanted to be a mother and month after month she found herself more and more discouraged. She didn’t share this with a lot of people and never sought medical due to the embarrassment of the situation. Luckily after 2 years she was able to conceive and give birth to a little girl.
    Through Dr. Smith’s story and what my friend has shared with me I am able to understand a little of the emotion that goes into the inability to conceive. I think it’s important for pharmacist to be understanding of these hardships and offer some emotional support.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I appreciated hearing from Dr. Smith on the issue of infertility based upon her own experiences. I do not personally know anyone who has utilized ART, but I believe that infertility is a very prevalent issue, especially for a couple who so desperately longs to have children of their own. I loved having the opportunity to listen to the reasoning behind why Dr. Smith chose the route that she did as well as hear about the difficulties that are associated with ART. Prior to this class, I knew that ART could be quite expensive, especially if a couple has to go through multiple rounds of therapy. However, I was unaware of the number of appointments per week and month that need to be made as well as how ART can take a toll on the working female’s schedule. I think that it is very important to take a number of factors into consideration prior to deciding to use ART.
    Like Kelsi, I also consider myself to be a pretty religious person and to have a strong sense of God’s presence. I agree with her in that I do not believe that “God made a couple infertile for a reason.” I also think that it is a couple’s choice and plan to be supportive toward those who choose to utilize ART as a pharmacist regardless of whether I agree or disagree with that choice.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I appreciated learning more than just the clinical aspects about this topic. I personally know a few families back home that had to use assisted reproduction therapies, and I honestly see no difference between the natural and IVF conceived children. Knowing more about the topic can only be a positive thing for us as pharmacists, as we will be able to talk to our patients easier.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hearing a personal story about assisted reproduction was very beneficial. I really loved the patient testimony side of this class and hearing the personal stories of patients who had experience with the topics we covered in class. Being able to hear Dr. Smith's story helped show me the harder side of that decision making process related to infertility. I feel that hearing her tell her story helped us to see the personal and emotional side of that process vs. the medical/scientific side we are used to learning about. I feel that her story will help me to understand and relate better to patients in the future who are going through a similar struggle.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I appreciated Dr. Smith being able to come in and talk to us about her personal experience. It was good to hear the thought process and the internal struggles that come with this decision.
    Personally, without hearing about the personal side, I don't think I ever would have heard about that perspective. I'm so used to in my own communities for these methods to be kind of a gold standard for reproduction, since so many couples are unable to conceive. I'm glad I got the opportunity to gain more empathy on this topic.

    ReplyDelete