Wednesday, February 22, 2017

February 13, 2017 Heart Disease in Women

Heart Disease and Women

We discussed heart disease in women and will have a guest come share her experience with heart disease.  Is there more you need to know?  

Do you understand the difference in presentation between men and women?  

We're you aware that women have a worse outcome from the first heart attack than men?  

This is one area that I think you can really see the effects of the FDA rule prohibiting Women in clinical trials because we have less gender specific information yet heart disease causes death in more women than all cancers combined.  What are your thoughts?  

Is there anything you wanted to know about heart disease or from our patient that didn't come out in her discussion? 

19 comments:

  1. I was only minimally aware of the differences between heart attacks in men and women before this class. We have always been taught that “women present slightly different than men” but never went into detail on the exact differences. I can easily see how predisposed conceptions of what might be ailing a woman (like stress or anxiety or breast cancer) could cloud the judgement of a doctor, but it still doesn’t make it right.

    Last year I had an anxiety attack in which I thought I was having a heart attack. I had chest pain, dizziness, and felt completely wrong to the point where couldn’t even drive. I went to the urgent care and the doctor immediately ran an EKG to rule out any heart conditions. I was highly relieved that it was not my heart, but after hearing the stories about other women who had actual heart attacks, I feel lucky that I was given an all-encompassing review of symptoms and wasn’t immediately ruled out for cardiovascular problems just because I was a seemingly healthy 23-year-old woman.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Before this class I was unaware of the differences in symptoms and presentation of heart disease/heart attacks in women compared to men. I assumed they were the same since men and women are treated the same in regard to heart medications. I typically have only heard about men having heart complications so I was really surprised to learn that women have poorer outcomes such as increased rates of re-infarction, heart failure, and death compared to men. This makes me wonder if the outcomes of women with heart disease would improve if there was female representation in clinical heart disease studies in order to develop female-specific treatment and not just assuming men and women are exactly the same.
    I think having our guest come and speak was eye-opening because we were able to see that a seemingly healthy person can even fall victim to heart disease and it is important to be able to identify the signs and symptoms.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I was unware of the differences in heart disease between men and women before this class. I remember hearing that heart attacks could present differently between men and women, but I did not know the distinct differences. The story shared in class about the woman who died from heart disease complications at an early age due to the misdiagnosis emphasized the serious impact that misconceptions can have on the overall wellbeing of the patient. I believe that the signs, symptoms, and presentation of heart disease, particularly heart attacks, in women should be public knowledge. There is a huge opportunity for education with this disease state and pharmacists can play a significant role in this endeavor. Overall, I think there needs to be a push for women in clinical trials so that we can obtain more gender-specific information.

    It was helpful to hear from a patient on this topic. Her experience encompassed many more events that I expected. It helped to reinforce that heart disease is a lifelong health issue that may be unexpected and that can affect anyone.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I only knew the idea that there was a difference in presentation between men and women in heart attacks, but I did not know the specifics of those differences. The ‘Go Red for Women’ video with Elizabeth Banks that we watched in class was awesome to highlight those differences. It seems odd that women present with more nonspecific signs when they have a heart attack versus men, like nausea, dizziness, and unexplained anxiety. That story about the young mother who went to three different hospitals and died after several undiagnosed heart attacks is horrendous, but I understand that she wouldn’t know they were heart attacks since the public doesn’t propagate that information well. The physicians who treated her, on the other hand, have no excuse; it’s their job.

    Also, I was not aware that women have worse outcomes from the first heart attack than men. I was shocked to learn this. Part of that shock came from the statistics (likelihood of dying is 50% in women versus 30% in men) and the other part came from my own personal experiences with female family members surviving several heart attacks (I now realize they are the anomalies, not the rule).

    Listening to the cardiovascular women’s health lecture was honestly depressing and disheartening hearing how many different major medications excluded women from trials, especially since disease of the heart is the most common killer of women. It made me angry to hear that the medical community has no recommendation regarding aspirin use as primary prevention of MI in women because they weren’t included in the study. Hearing that statins have questionable efficacy and a higher mortality in women makes me not want to recommend their use in my future female patients. Plus, it’s truly ironic that hypertension studies used white men when hypertension is more common in blacks and more common in women greater than 55 years old. It all kind of makes you lose a little bit of faith in the healthcare system.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Before we talked about heart disease in class, I knew that men and women presented differently but did not know the specifics. I was also unaware that women have worse outcomes than men after their first heart attack.
    I would definitely agree that we need more research regarding women and heart disease. This is such a big problem that women were excluded considering they are so different from men in this regard. I would love to see studies that look at both men and women and research the major differences in presentation as well as best treatment options based on gender. I also think it could be beneficial to see women only studies to look at the variety of treatment options and which agents are associated with the best outcomes.
    With heart disease being something that runs in my family, I am thankful to have more information on the topic specific to women.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Prior to this discussion, I was aware of the fact that women can experience different presentation of heart attacks than men. I knew that their "typical" presentation differs from what people anticipate because the "typical" presentation we learn about is for men. It is important to educate people, especially women about the differences in symptoms so that they can identify what is going on in their body and not put off care. I was not aware of the difference in prognosis following a heart attack, but I think that women could have worse outcomes following a heart attack be because they may not have as much urgency in seeking care because they are unaware of what is going on or the seriousness of their symptoms.
    It is important to understand that all of the drugs we use for heart attacks were tested for both safety and efficacy in males. We have talked all semester about how men and women are not physiologically the same. It is important to monitor women for efficacy and side effects following starting new medications because they can react differently than males and what may be best for someone may not be best for someone else. It is important to educate women on heart disease in general because it is so prevalent. Many women know the risks of breast cancer and other gender specific disease states, but I think that heart disease is commonly overlooked as a major contributor to morbidity and mortality for women.
    I enjoyed hearing the patient testimonial about her experience with heart disease because it encompassed many areas of concern for women and potential outcomes that could result from heart disease. There is alot to consider for patients in terms of care. For women and men both, it is important to consider pros and cons of certain treatment options. The benefits and risks are important for both genders, but may differ between men and women. It is important to consider the differences in men and women when treating heart disease and related conditions.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I knew that heart disease was a leading cause of death in women; but I guess I wasn’t aware of how different the presentation of heart attacks are between men and women. I was also unaware that women had worse outcomes than men following a heart attack. The video we watched was very informational on the uncharacteristic signs of an infarction. Most people know about the chest tightness, shooting pain in the left arm, shortness of breath, etc. The video was able to highlight some of the other symptoms, such as sweating, fatigue, and weakness.

    The woman in the video was quoted, “Do I look like someone who has a heart attack?” I think this made a great point that women don’t always take the time to think about themselves when they are taking care of their family; or society pictures men as more prone to heart attacks. My aunt experienced a heart attack and she did not present with the typical risk factors such as obesity or family history. Overall, it was helpful to learn more about the symptoms women present.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Growing up I have always been very aware of heart disease because it is prevalent in my mothers side of the family. My great grandfather died at the age of 45 of a major heart attack and my grandfather had his first heart attack at the age of 36. He went on to have two more heart attacks and multiple bypass surgeries. My mother's cholesterol regularly runs the the upper 300's and she has frequent chest pains. As soon as we had this lecture in class I made sure that she knew the signs of heart attacks are different in women than in men. I never realized that the classic signs didn't apply to everyone. I believe this will be very important when I become a community pharmacist to inform all patients of signs and symptoms that are specific to their gender. I as not aware that women have a worse outcome from the first heart attack and I believe that a lot more education needs to happen in order to save women's lives. This can begin with us as future pharmacists educating our communities.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I was not aware before this class that men and women can have different signs and symptoms of a heart attack. I also did not know that women has worse outcomes than men. I feel like it is something I should have known, given that I am a female and that my grandmother died of a heart attack. She was in her 70s, so I think that is why I did not pay much attention to it and this was about10 years ago, so I was much younger. But it makes sense hearing the statistics about women surviving their first heart attack compared to men (this was her first heart attack). I really appreciated the speaker coming in and tell us her story.
    There are so many commercials on TV today about different disease states and how to get informed. I would really like to see more informative announcements about women and heart disease. There are a few out there (like we saw in class), but it should be more widely talked about and more women should be aware.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Over the past few months, recordings have been playing at my pharmacy about heart disease in women. It has statistics and symptoms and encourages listeners to share the information with women in their life so that they can be taken care of. I think that messages like these are important and I am glad that they do them. Similar to what the commercial we watched portrayed, I think a lot of women have a me-second mentality. They want to make sure their family and household is taken care of even if that means they ignore their own needs. Many women will find themselves in a situation where they would rather sacrifice their own time and energy helping others, especially their family, than take care of themselves. It was helpful to discuss the difference between male and female presentation more specifically so that I can share that information with patients and people in my life.
    I liked hearing the first hand experience we were able to hear, but I think it also made it more real for me. Hearing about the diseases and risk factors is one thing, but hearing about it happening to someone and their specific experience proves that it can happen to anyone. It makes me worry more than I had before because it can come on unexpectedly and is an emergent situation in most cases. My mom would be someone who could easily write off or ignore chest pain or shortness of breath like our speaker discussed. She wouldn’t go to the doctor to get it checked out, she would just suffer through it because that is her personality. She would continue to go to work and make sure my little sister gets to her activities and has everything she needs. The thought that she could let something like this go on, scares me. I am going to use the information we learned to continually educate her on heart disease to make sure she is taking care of herself.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I was surprised to learn how much more women are affected by heart disease compared to men. As I was growing up I commonly associated heart attacks with men more so than women, probably because of the people I knew who have had a heart attack and the way it is portrayed via the media. I was aware that there were different heart attack presentations between men and women but I can see how it may be overlooked by a woman if she was not aware of the symptoms just because we don’t hear much about them and they are typically the last of the family to seek care. The commercial/announcement that we watched in class had a lot of good information that could be beneficial for women to see because it portrayed a scene that probably happens more often than not. It was scary to learn how common this disease is among women and I think the more we are able to learn and teach others about what to look for the better off we all can be to receive proper care.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I never was aware that men and women experienced heart attacks in their own ways. Seeing that we have all of these medications out on the market that work well for men for heart disease makes me think that we are highly unlikely to see anything in the future for women. This can faulted by the FDA who did not allow women in their studies when these drugs were in clinical trials. Since the bodies of both men and women are different, they both interact differently with the way they might metabolize the drug. Unfortunately we don't have a very good way to dose such heart disease medications for women in order to prevent it in the future for them.
    I also thought that it was interesting that during the pharmacy curriculum we never really learned about the difference between men and women in heart disease until this class. It seemed that we only learned the common symptoms that most men would have in regards to heart attacks and I think this is detrimental with the development of new medications. This makes me want to know if the medical field is trying to make a new type of medication that would be designed specifically for women with heart disease.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I knew heart disease was an important topic in women, but I don't think I understood the magnitude. I don't ever think of women when I am picturing a heart attack. I think that the commercial with Elizabeth Banks was the most helpful thing I saw in relation to this topic. I think it truly depicted what an actual woman would be going through and her response. The mentality to keep going and keep providing, putting other people before yourself - it would be difficult to change just because you are feeling a little off.
    Between this commercial we watched and our guest speaker, I think that there needs to be more awareness about what heart attacks look like in women. I have begun to hear commercials on the radio about F.A.S.T. for heart attacks. I don't think they even mention that these symptoms can differ in women. It is kind of scary the lack of information we get about the differences between the two.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I thought it was great to discuss this topic and not only helpful for us in our own lives, but as healthcare professionals. The video we watched depicting the woman having a heart attack really struck me. She said in the video that she was too young to have a heart attack, and watching it, I realized I would feel the exact same way. Women can have heart attacks when they are young and fit or when they are older and have known heart disease, but the latter is what instantly comes to my mind when I picture someone suffering from a heart attack. It was actually really scary to think about.
    I didn't really consider that a woman's symptoms during a heart attack may be different than a man's prior to this discussion, so I was glad we covered that as well. I loved getting to hear from our guest speaker on her experience, especially since she was younger when she had her heart attack and has her implanted device.
    I definitely was not aware that woman can have worse outcomes from their first heart attack than men. When Dr. VanTyle talked about the patient who had multiple heart attacks and even though she went to the ED like she was supposed to, was still not even worked up for a heart attack, it made me realize that a lot more education needs to be happening within healthcare professions. We, as pharmacists and as women, can be spreading awareness about this sort of thing to protect future patients from something like this happening to them.

    ReplyDelete
  15. While I was aware that women and men present differently, I did not know not know the specific differences in presentation. My grandpa had a heart attack at age 75, and it killed him instantly. I am not sure how the heart attack specifically affected him because my grandma was in another room when it happened. He is the only one in my family who I am aware of who has suffered from a heart-related issue. However, hearing from the class' guest speaker made me realize that heart attacks can happen to anyone, as she didn't have a family history of heart attacks.

    I also did not know women's survival rate compared to men is much lower when they have heart attacks. Women especially need to be educated on the signs and symptoms of heart attacks to ensure they get immediate assistance when they do experience these heart attack symptoms. Education may prove to be the only way to help increase a woman's survival if she does experience a heart attack.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Throughout my duration of college, I have been surrounded by many influential individuals, as well as organizations. Alpha Phi is one of the organizations that I have been blessed to a part of throughout my duration at Butler. The Alpha Phi Foundation consists of Women's Heart Health. With this being stated, I have been a participant and advocate for women's heart health through various activities and events.

    As a pharmacist, I can continue to be an advocate and promoter of the importance of overall women's health, especially heart health as it affects many individuals and families. Realizing the abnormal symptoms and outcomes for women will be influential to my patient's as these detrimental events can happen to anyone at any time in their life.

    In addition to my involvement with Alpha Phi, I currently work in the emergency department as a medication reconciliation technician. Throughout my time in the emergency department, I have seen and experienced many issues associated with heart conditions. These issues are extremely prevalent, in which I have began to realize the importance of heart health in both men and women.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I had heard about the difference in presentation between men and women, but the only time I had seen these differences talked about was in small social advocacy groups and in talks and lectures that focus on women’s health. It’s shocking that we don’t talk about it in the general health class, but it also brings into grim prespective why women have worse outcomes (I think we may have touch on that point in therapeutics during that section, but that never had a real frame of reference).

    My mother’s friend had a heart attack last summer while they were driving. Thankfully she was a fairl experienced nurse and my mother is a worry wart so they got to the hospital in time. I worry what would happen to a similar woman without the same background in healthcare. She’s the type of person who is the primary provider for many different levels in her family. Her mother, her children, and her grandchildren all rely on her in some way. She has a habit of ignoring her own comfort and health to help others (she broke her foot earlier this summer and didn’t go to the hospital because she didn’t want the meds to make her too fuzzy to help). Had she done that here, she may not be around now.

    It’d be nice if we could discuss the difference more than just in specialized groups.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Before going to class I had no idea heart disease presented differently in men and women. I learned the signs which commonly present in men; the chest pain and discomfort along with the shortness of breath. But the jaw pain, nausea/vomiting, and back pain which present more frequently in women were unknown to me. The fact that this wasn’t stressed in the normal curriculum frightens me. I had no idea that heart disease was the number one killer of women. Pharmacists; being the most assessible health care professionals, need to be able to identify these signs and risk factors.
    Upon an internet search I was able to find a news article that highlighted these differences. It gave interesting statistics such as women with hypertension being more likely to die of heart disease than men. The article also pointed out that a younger women with diabetes is 4-5 times more likely to have a heart attack when compared to her male counterpart.
    I was encouraged to see that there is an effort to make this information more well-known and I hope that, in the future, the risks/signs of heart disease in women become more common knowledge. http://www.today.com/health/heart-disease-different-women-may-be-deadlier-t69061

    ReplyDelete
  19. Prior to this class, I was aware that there were slight differences between men and women regarding heart attacks, but I was unaware as to what these slight differences were. In pharmacy school, we have been taught about the signs and symptoms of heart attacks. However, when learning such information, I didn’t realize that the signs and symptoms we were learning about only really referred to the presentation of a heart attack in males. I believe that this is a very important topic to acknowledge and talk about with healthcare professionals to ensure the proper care of women with heart disease, especially since women have a worse outcome from the first heart attack than men. Overall, I think that further clinical trials need to be completed to obtain more information specific to women.
    Additionally, I thought that hearing from the patient was very informative, as she believed that she was quite healthy at the time of her original heart attack. She didn’t necessarily know the signs and symptoms, and for this reason I believe that we need to provide further education to our female patients.

    ReplyDelete