Were there any surprises for you in the America the Beautiful movie? This video is on the Photoshop Effect (it is 5 minutes long but very interesting) .
How dangerous for younger girls and young men to believe what they see? Does that relate to stats you have seen on bullying, eating disorders, anxiety and depression. Share your thoughts and comments. What is the sibling or parent role to normalize the expectations?
I was extremely surprised by the 12 year old model. I feel as though that would be very damaging to her mental health and especially self-esteem in the long-run. Her self-confidence and views of herself currently appear high, but at that young of an age if she thinks that herself-worth is solely based upon her physical appearance, that will be extremely detrimental in the future when she can't depend only on her looks and will essentially feel worthless. This could lead to her feeling depressed and anxious.
ReplyDeleteIt is very dangerous for younger girls and men to believe what they see in the media. If young women believe that they are supposed to be stick thin, have big boobs, big butt, perfect skin and hair, etc then they are always going to feel imperfect and not beautiful. This will lead to unhealthy habits like eating disorders as well as depression and anxiety. By displaying all these images of photo shopped, perfect women, it not only directly affects women, but it affects how men view women as well. Like the example of the man in the movie who basically only views women as sexual-objects and expects the women that he is with to basically be models at all times. This only puts more pressure on women to strive to be perfect, when perfect is not attainable for anyone.
I honestly think that a parents' role to normalize expectations is to make a point to focus on feeling good and being healthy regarding eating habits and exercise, but not to focus on size and weight. Also I think parents tend to constantly tell their daughters they are beautiful, but forget to tell them they are smart, funny, kind, etc (things that are not superficial). By assuring your daughter that they have other characteristics that are important, if not more important, than beauty will lead them to be more confident in the future.
Regarding the movie, I thought the first portion about advertising and fashion was really interesting. One of the advertising executives said that marketing and advertising probably started as establishing a problem and setting yourself (or product) as the solution. On the flip side, one of the fashion photographers said that they’re selling a dream. I thought this was interesting because the media very much dictates what “solution” the general public should want which is often impossible to attain, and the entire movie talked regarding around this central idea. This was best shown when the Harvard sociologist discussed Fiji before and after TV was introduced. I think this all relates to stats on depression, anxiety, and eating disorders as mentioned in the post because adolescents as well as young men and women are constantly being sold this idea of who they should be. If they don’t conform to this, then that disconnect can manifest into very real disorders especially since young people have such a strong desire to belong.
ReplyDeleteThe Photoshop Effect video in the comment was surprisingly shocking! America the Beautiful had a section showing what a woman looked like before the make-up and photo editing versus the end product, but this short video really forces home the point that pictures in the media are drastically changed from the original. The most interesting part to me was seeing that the guy was adjusting the pictures little by little, so one could maybe think it would look like the original, but all those small changes created a totally different image.
I thought the movie was very interesting and revealed a lot of things to me that I had never thought about. I was astonished by the 12 year old model. I could not believe a girl so young was living the lifestyle of an adult in such a tough industry. The movie honestly made me feel less confident in our ability as a society to change and stop portraying women in an unrealistic way. When they interviewed the editors and photographers and they essentially stated that that this is just the way it is and that this is what sells, it felt disheartening. I think this concept and this image that we create is extremely unhealthy for young girls and women. It also sets up unrealistic expectations for young boys and men about what women are expected to look like and what is considered beautiful. Mothers and women in general can set an example for their daughters of what true beauty looks like and try to create a positive environment and body image for their daughters starting at a young age.
ReplyDeleteI wish I was more surprised about the America the Beautiful video than I was. Society puts unrealistic expectations on women in regards to appearance which is evident in most media outlets. Women are constantly told to fit a particular mold that society creates and it can be detrimental in terms of emotional and mental health. What also goes unnoticed is the image of men that is displayed in the media, as well. Men are exemplified as muscular, fit, and tough. Both images of men and women in the media can be dangerous particularly for young adults. Middle school is usually deemed “the awkward years” for most people. It is also the age that children are more exposed to media and being compared to the images by their peers. This directly compares to the statistics on bullying, eating disorders, anxiety, and depression. I believe parents and siblings have an opportunity to intervene in these situations. I think parents should constantly reinforce that the negative images in the media are not representative of reality and try to limit media exposure if at all possible. Siblings can also serve as a support system in these matters.
ReplyDeleteAlthough these issues are still quite prevalent in society, I do believe we are starting to move in a more positive direction. While completing the Women and Media assignment, I noticed that the magazines directed at teenagers displayed a wider range of body types and promoted strong, confident, and ambitious women. When I was a teenager, those same magazines did not do that—they displayed the typical unrealistic standards. It is encouraging that as a society, people are beginning to address the issues surrounding media and the role it has on developing men and women.
While society may have unrealistic expectations for women, I think it really does start with how you are raised in your home. Growing up, I have always had a bigger build than most girls. My calves - huge - always. But instead of feeling bad about it, my mom would make me feel good about myself for having muscle and being a strong person. She would let me know that was nothing wrong with me and I should be proud of who I am - no matter what other people say. I was bullied in grade school about not having thin, skinny legs and I specifically remember telling a girl - "Would you prefer it if my muscles and bones were showing though my skin? That's all that is under there." Sassy move on my part, but it was all I could get out. I couldn't really understand what they wanted me to do - that is just what it was. I don't think that this was acceptable behavior then and definitely not now. I think it is horrible that female to female we tear each other down. We get enough of that from the media and from men that it blows my mind when women do that to each other. I think that no girl should be judged for size - big or small - because it only perpetuates the problem and hurts ourselves. Again, I think it starts with what happens before you are even exposed to the media. Hopefully before the negativity gets to us, we can be taught to be true to ourselves and be happy with what we have. No doubt, it would be easier if the media was not creating these unattainable images, but we need to learn to not let that consume us.
ReplyDeleteI was also surprised about the 12 year old in the video. I think she could have definitely pursued her dreams of becoming a model later on in life and it would have been much more appropriate. It was amazing to me that even though she was motivated to become a model, her mother was so insistent that she continue and seemed to push her in the direction of that career at such a young age. I don’t think it is good for such a young girl to be surrounded by an industry like that and grow up not knowing anything different. In today’s world with so much social media being used by such young people, it can be dangerous for them to be constantly reminded of A-list celebrities and fashion models and not be aware that in reality very few people actually have what is considered to be a perfect body.
ReplyDeleteI also found it interesting when it showed the interviews with the magazine editors and advertisers and how they were basically saying without the advertisements or magazines there as a way to advertise, they would not have jobs. It brought a different perspective that I had not considered about that industry; even though they realized some of the messages being portrayed in the ads were not very positive, they were comfortable printing them since it guaranteed their job.
I actually enjoyed watching America the Beautiful. It was startling, but also told a story I think we all know to be true. What people think is"beautiful" plays a very large role in our lives. The day after watching this film in class I was babysitting. The family has a 9 year old girl in third grade. As we were watching TV, a commercial for Maybelline came on. The little girl's face lit up and she said, "Oh! That's Gigi! I love her. She is soooo pretty wow." I was totally shocked. In my opinion, 9 is way too young to know who supermodels are and look up to them as role models. Another example: recently my friend was on the phone with her mom. My friend has been thinking her hair is thinning and has gone to a doctor who prescribed something for her to grow thicker hair again. (I haven't noticed a difference in her hair over the past 4 years of knowing her, but I'm sure it is upsetting to her if she really does see a difference.) So my friend's mom on the phone told my friend that "Beauty is everything. Without it, you don't have anything. Have you picked up your creams from the pharmacy yet? And how's the weight? You know sometimes its hard but you may just need to work out a second time some days or not be eating so much." This was so sad to me. My parents have never said anything like this to me. We all laughed at it saying how extreme her mom was being and things like "thanks for the confidence mom." But I knew deep down she believed it. She knew she had to be as "perfect" as she could for her mom. She also told us of times her mother comments on her clothing choices and often tells her she has gained wait at school and will actually starve her while she is home, saying things like how there's water in the fridge she doesn't need a snack. and dinner will be a salad. Beauty and perfection have consumed my friend's mother. The woman in the video posted above was correct. Girls know they use photoshop in magazines, but I don't think we know to what extent. People do almost anything to look like these people on magazine covers, when it's probably close to impossible.
ReplyDeleteMaybe alopecia in women would be a good topic for you. I have some references. When do women lose hair and why? Right after childbirth is one time. Let me know if you are interested
DeleteI thought America the Beautiful was an eye opening movie. I was amazed to see that magazines and super model industries would go as far as hiring a 12 year old girl to model their clothing just because of how mature she looked at the time. When viewers see this 12 year old girl modeling and don't know her age, they start to get self-conscious because they see this skinny girl and then look at themselves and wonder why they can't be that skinny too. I understand that the magazines believe that they won't sell magazines if they don't pick the right people to model for them but when they continue to distort the image by photoshopping every single feature of the model, it continues to grow the problem we see today of people harming themselves to look "pretty".
ReplyDeleteOne thing that I have noticed over the last few years was how photoshop has played a role in my classmates and my lives over the year with high school senior photos without many people taking notice. Maybe I feel this way because I was so against getting them at the time, but looking at peoples senior photos and their actual photos they take, you see a huge difference. The senior photos distort the image and give something that doesn't really resemble the actual person. I always disliked when people told me how well my senior photos turned out because I could see that that wasn't how I actually looked and was more of something I could only dream of looking like.
I thought America the Beautiful was an eye opening movie. I was amazed to see that magazines and super model industries would go as far as hiring a 12 year old girl to model their clothing just because of how mature she looked at the time. When viewers see this 12 year old girl modeling and don't know her age, they start to get self-conscious because they see this skinny girl and then look at themselves and wonder why they can't be that skinny too. I understand that the magazines believe that they won't sell magazines if they don't pick the right people to model for them but when they continue to distort the image by photoshopping every single feature of the model, it continues to grow the problem we see today of people harming themselves to look "pretty".
ReplyDeleteOne thing that I have noticed over the last few years was how photoshop has played a role in my classmates and my lives over the year with high school senior photos without many people taking notice. Maybe I feel this way because I was so against getting them at the time, but looking at peoples senior photos and their actual photos they take, you see a huge difference. The senior photos distort the image and give something that doesn't really resemble the actual person. I always disliked when people told me how well my senior photos turned out because I could see that that wasn't how I actually looked and was more of something I could only dream of looking like.
I was not very surprised by most of what I saw in the movie. It is something that I have seen many people in my life struggle with. I do believe that the movie should be watched by more young adults to help them realize that help is available and that many people also struggle with this issue. I also believe that young adults should be exposed to photoshop and the many changes made in images in magazines today. They would then realize how false the images in magazines are. I always knew that images in magazines were photoshopped but I never imagined that they were altered that much. I figured that they covered up a zit or two or helped their complexion. The Photoshop effect video really opened my eyes to the extreme changes made with photoshop. Overall I really enjoyed the movie although it was sad, because it can be a great resource for people who might not know how to handle the feelings they are going through.
ReplyDeleteAmerica the Beautiful was an interesting and thought-provoking movie. It seems to me that society is used to the unrealistic images of women and is aware of the usage of photoshop. However, society still seeks that image. I was very surprised by the 12-year-old model. Although she was very mature, that type of career had to be damaging to a young girl’s self-esteem. I can’t imagine having all of those eyes on you while your body is going through so many changes. It is hard enough growing up in the average middle school and high school.
ReplyDeleteThe photoshop video was a little surprising. Like I said, most of society is aware that photoshopped is regularly utilized. However, I think people would still be surprised to see to what extent the tools are used and what features are actually changed. The model in that video was already beautiful and fit, but yet they adjusted her appearance greatly. Phrases that stuck out to me from the video include “impossible image,” “prettier with photoshop,” “idea of perfection,” and “out of control.” America is aware of the illusion, but pushes women to try to attain it.
It did surprise me that there was a 12 year old model succeeding in the industry. I do not necessarily think that it was a bad thing that she was pursuing this opportunity. If this is what she wanted to do then I think that she should be able to it without criticism from others. I thought it was great that she was so confident in herself and her body but I hope it was not solely based on her appearance. When her modeling career starts to decline, I hope that she still has the same confidence in herself and her personality.
ReplyDeleteI think that young girls today are surrounded with expectations about their body and what they should look like to be beautiful. This can be damaging to their self esteem when they do not have the “ideal” body. Parents, friends, and other people with influence in their lives should always be supportive of them and their body to help them build their self esteem. There are going to be plenty of peers that want to bring them down for not looking perfect, so I hope that these influential people in their lives are supporting them.
I coach girls in gymnastics a few nights a week and have done so all through pharmacy school. Right now I coach girls from ages 3 to 13. I see kids with all body types—skinny, muscular, larger build, short, and tall. Most of my time at the gym is spent with my competitive team of girls ages 6-10. I think this is an important stage in their lives and I realize that the other coaches and I have a huge influence in their lives as role models and authority figures. I am always very careful about how I talk with these girls. Although gymnastics is commonly thought of as a sport where you have to be thin, like ballet in one of the films we watched, I support all of them and I never bring up weight or body type to them. I try to build their confidence in themselves as they achieve their goals in the sport and hopefully that translates to a positive self image in other aspects of their lives.
I really enjoyed this movie; as most have mentioned above, the most shocking thing shown was the 12-year old model. At first glance, she appeared to be in her early-mid 20s. But as soon as she smiled, you could see many baby teeth. The girl's innocent, young personality also shined through when asked by the interviewer what she expected to see in New York when she was there for fashion week ("The Big Apple").
ReplyDeleteIt was depressing to see that the girls's mother immersed her in the fashion industry at such a young age. Her whole life will surely be difficult because she will constantly be struggling with her body image. We soon find out in the movie that she stops booking the "big" jobs. Because of this, she loses confidence in her looks, and her mindset will forever be affected by this.
This movie should be shown to girls at a young age to prove and ingrain in their psyches that being "model-thin" is simply unrealistic for most women. Even so, models are commonly photo-shopped in magazines.
yes - I agree. Kids should not have to fulfill a Mother's dream. I wonder if she would have persisted without her Mother pushing her forward. Ultimately she ages out.= and it is very hard for her
DeleteI thought that the movie was very interesting. I appreciated that it pointed out the unattainable standards that the fashion industry has. The 12 year-old model was a good example of that. She was made to look as though she was a grown woman, when she definitely was not. The fact that they portray a 12-year-old's body as the perfect body for a grown woman to have is ridiculous. I think the way the fashion industry works has a very negative impact on young women. Seeing women who are stick thin and being told that they are what you want to look like can have a major impact on self-esteem. Having the body of a model is not realistic for most women, and I feel that since most women aren't able to get that body it makes many feel as though they aren't good enough.
ReplyDeleteI feel that the media and fashion industry play a big role in the stats related to eating disorders in particular. It makes sense that young people see images that they believe are real and will do almost anything to try to become like them. That being said, I can also see how this could lead to depression or anxiety. When someone tries and tries to be something that isn't even real and isn't able to achieve that it could most definitely lead to increased incidence of depression or anxiety. I also feel that the standards our society sets with regard to weight plays a big role in bullying. Young kids are awful to other kids if they are even a little chubbier than most. Which, again, could increase their risk of developing an eating disorder, depression, and/or anxiety as a result of the bullying.
I feel like the whole situation has gotten out of control. I feel that it is extremely important for parents of young children to teach them at an early age that what they see is not always the truth. I think that explaining to them that magazines and other media outlets use photoshop constantly so that any image they see is likely not the original. I also feel that it can be vital to set realistic expectations and not let them think that being model thin is normal or even healthy for most people. Raising young children's self-esteem at an early age and helping them to understand the way images are manipulated could be so helpful for them as they grow up.
I thought that the movie was very interesting. I appreciated that it pointed out the unattainable standards that the fashion industry has. The 12 year-old model was a good example of that. She was made to look as though she was a grown woman, when she definitely was not. The fact that they portray a 12-year-old's body as the perfect body for a grown woman to have is ridiculous. I think the way the fashion industry works has a very negative impact on young women. Seeing women who are stick thin and being told that they are what you want to look like can have a major impact on self-esteem. Having the body of a model is not realistic for most women, and I feel that since most women aren't able to get that body it makes many feel as though they aren't good enough.
ReplyDeleteI feel that the media and fashion industry play a big role in the stats related to eating disorders in particular. It makes sense that young people see images that they believe are real and will do almost anything to try to become like them. That being said, I can also see how this could lead to depression or anxiety. When someone tries and tries to be something that isn't even real and isn't able to achieve that it could most definitely lead to increased incidence of depression or anxiety. I also feel that the standards our society sets with regard to weight plays a big role in bullying. Young kids are awful to other kids if they are even a little chubbier than most. Which, again, could increase their risk of developing an eating disorder, depression, and/or anxiety as a result of the bullying.
I feel like the whole situation has gotten out of control. I feel that it is extremely important for parents of young children to teach them at an early age that what they see is not always the truth. I think that explaining to them that magazines and other media outlets use photoshop constantly so that any image they see is likely not the original. I also feel that it can be vital to set realistic expectations and not let them think that being model thin is normal or even healthy for most people. Raising young children's self-esteem at an early age and helping them to understand the way images are manipulated could be so helpful for them as they grow up.
I thought the movie was interesting and in some parts surprising. I was surprised by the 12 year old model. She was personifying a much older character. I was impressed by her self-confidence and positive body image. I do think entering such a strict field so early could lead to potential issues later on. When she is not so desirable or is not booking as many jobs as she was previously, her self confidence could be hurt. Her early success could lead to disappointment later in a field where looks are such a high priority. Even a beautiful girl like her may develop body image issues because her success is measured by her ability to get modeling jobs.
ReplyDeleteIt could be dangerous for young boys and girls to believe what they see. At a young age, children who want to change their image to fit in more or like themselves more do not know how to do it in the proper way. They will likely go to extremes and partake in unhealthy behaviors to get results.
It is very important to teach children to respect themselves and others, regardless of appearance or possible differences from others. It is important for children to understand that the expectations of society may not live up to the depictions in modern media. It is important to educate on health goals, rather than a specific unrealistic size.
I thought the movie was interesting and in some parts surprising. I was surprised by the 12 year old model. She was personifying a much older character. I was impressed by her self-confidence and positive body image. I do think entering such a strict field so early could lead to potential issues later on. When she is not so desirable or is not booking as many jobs as she was previously, her self confidence could be hurt. Her early success could lead to disappointment later in a field where looks are such a high priority. Even a beautiful girl like her may develop body image issues because her success is measured by her ability to get modeling jobs.
ReplyDeleteIt could be dangerous for young boys and girls to believe what they see. At a young age, children who want to change their image to fit in more or like themselves more do not know how to do it in the proper way. They will likely go to extremes and partake in unhealthy behaviors to get results.
It is very important to teach children to respect themselves and others, regardless of appearance or possible differences from others. It is important for children to understand that the expectations of society may not live up to the depictions in modern media. It is important to educate on health goals, rather than a specific unrealistic size.
I was stunned to hear about the girl who was a model at the age of 13. She looked like 13 going on 23 but yet no one in the industry really stopped to think about the consequences and impact on her mental health that could arise from the experience. It sets a precedence to the other girls in the world that if she could do it, maybe I could to. Or on the negative side, I will never be as good as her. The influence of the media and advertising in general is a huge factor in the mental health of younger children. Both men and women have predefined images thrown at them from the time that they turn on a television or read a magazine.
ReplyDeleteI found it interesting that out of the many magazines that we brought in for class, the ones that had the more provocative and borderline inappropriate images were in the teen magazines. It is a horrible message to send to kids that being underweight is “cool” that you have to have the perfect body, the clothes, the makeup, sex appeal, etc. I think this directly correlates to the stats on bullying, eating disorders, anxiety, and depression
You are one of the first to mention the magazine pictures. Think about the images and the amount of Photoshop time they have had and it is mind boggling.
DeleteI really enjoyed the movie. It surprised me in some ways, and other ways not so much. As a kid, I never really idolized models or the people that were shown in magazines. I never pictured them as "real people" and I didn't think they lived real lives like I did either. But unlike me, other kids and teens do look up to them and strive to look like them. I think it is a major reason for all of the eating disorders we have in our society. Parents have a huge role in normalizing their children's expectations. They should know models in magazines and tv are photo shopped to look perfect and that fashion models face a lot of hardships and struggles to get to where they are. In regards to the 12 year old model in the movie, I think there should be laws in place that restrict people less than a certain age from modeling. You have to be at least 14 to work in the state of Indiana and that should apply to modeling as well, since it is a job. Although I think that 14 is even too young. These young models should enjoy high school and worry about one thing at a time.
ReplyDeleteI thought it was cool to see how photoshopping actually works. I was not one bit surprised by the video though. I hope that people in society aren't naive to the fact that 99.9% of pictures in magazines are photoshopped.
As many of my classmates have said, I am in agreement with their shock of the young model in the movie, "America the Beautiful." It is astounding to believe the mother of the young girl was in agreement and supportive with her modeling career, as this sent messages to her that were inappropriate for her age. This particular situation sends negative messages and connotations to not only younger girls, but to adults as well. Our society has a specific image associated with beauty, in which both men and women strive to obtain this particular identity. Although we can never get rid of advertising in entirety, we can be advocates for healthy lifestyles and promote general well-being for the youth in our community.
ReplyDeleteAmerica the Beautiful really opened my eyes to the full extent at which our culture fixates on ascetic beauty. I was particularity fascinated by Gerren Taylor and decided to look into where she is today. The results were fairly tragic. At 14, just 2 years after her debut, she was thrown out of the modeling world after growing to a size 4 (average 16-18). Her self-esteem plummeted as the people who praised her purely for her beauty shunned her. She soon developed an eating disorder.
ReplyDelete“At first, I was like, Whatever! So I went to Paris and London to see if maybe I could model there. And they said, ‘No, you have to be a size 0, or negative.’ I didn’t even know negative existed. After that, I came back to the States and I was really depressed. I developed an eating disorder and wasn’t eating. It was really hard for me and I thought I was ugly.”
I can’t help but feel so sorry for this young girl and empathize with what little childhood she had. I was born in the 99th percentile in height and being 6’2” today I’ve always been quite a bit taller than my classmates. Never fitting in physically was hard and I can only imagine what it would have felt like to not only be accepted for looking different, but to be praised for it. Then, to have it all come crashing down, for being a healthy weight, in just two short years must have been heart breaking. I hope for the best for Gerren, and I hope that she will learn to see that being called “beautiful” by strangers really isn’t the only ambition a woman can hold.
I was very surprised by the America the Beautiful movie, and I was absolutely baffled by the 12-year-old model. It was crazy to me that she wanted to be a part of such a tough industry that only values the look of a certain physique. It was even crazier that her mother was pushing her and encouraging her in this industry. Even though her self-esteem was high to begin with, trying to keep up with the industry could lead to feelings of worthlessness and depression. Additionally, I think that it is extremely unrealistic to have a model so young who is modeling clothing made for women in their 20s and 30s.
ReplyDeleteI think that it is very dangerous for younger girls and young men to believe what they see in magazines, on television, and on billboards. Each of those photos, with the exception of the photos of a few companies who have vowed not to retouch their photos, is photoshopped. The photos are not real and depict an unattainable “perfection.” This leads younger girls and young men to believe that they will only be beautiful or popular if they look like the model in the media. I believe that these images do have a direct correlation to bullying, eating disorders, anxiety, and depression. In order to normalize the expectations, I think that parents and siblings should put an emphasis on exercise, healthy eating habits, and other healthy habits while reassuring their children that they are beautiful just the way they are.