This discussion is one that many in pharmacy should think about. Whether we agree or disagree personally is not the point. These people deserve our caring and compassionate services and understanding. How comfortable are you? What more do you need to learn? Do you need to unlearn some misinformation or prejudice? In some countries (Kenya for example) saying you are LGBT is a death sentence. What more should we do? Do you have any LGBT patients/clients that come to your pharmacy. Would seeing them in your hometown be different than seeing these same patients here in Indianapolis? Any comments on the video we saw from the NY Public Health Department?
I think this was a very important topic to cover, especially when referring to medical care. I was very surprised to learn that LGBTQQA individuals were either given poor medical care or even got turned down for medical care once their providers found out their sexual preference or who they identified as. Our duty as medical providers is to provide our patients great care without judgement. We want our patients to feel safe so they feel comfortable sharing their medical concerns in order for us to provide the most accurate and effective medical care.
ReplyDeleteI have previously had conversations with people who are against gay rights. When I ask for their reasoning, their argument is, "because my religion says so". Like we briefly mentioned in class, I don't think this is an appropriate argument in any situation, but especially medical care. It is not appropriate to impose your beliefs on someone you are supposed to be treating and taking care of, especially if your beliefs will get in the way of their medical care and health. People can tell when you disapprove of the way they are living their life and if you are just trying to get them in and out of your clinic as fast as possible. LGBTQQA patients deserve just as much, if not more medical attention from us due to the increased incidence of emotional distress, depression, suicide attempts, domestic violence, and hate crimes in this population.
I need to learn more about the hormone regimens in the trans population. I would not know enough to counsel on drug interactions, health risks, common side effects, etc.
I think as medical providers we can help the LGBTQQA community by educating ourselves more on their medication regimens, common procedures performed, and ways to make their practice more inclusive (revising medical forms to have more gender neutral terms, knowing what pronouns the patient prefers to be referred as, marketing LGBT establishments, etc.)
I think we still have a long way to go in order for LGBTQQA individuals feel safe and comfortable in the pharmacy/health clinic/hospital, but I think addressing that there is an issue and talking about ways to fix it and making conscious decisions to change your way of thinking is a good first step.
I had never really thought about how important it was to be familiar with these topics in terms of healthcare until we worked on our assignment last semester. We are most definitely going to be having these individuals as our patients and I think that the best way we are able to care for them is to be familiar with how they may be treated (such as transgender individuals) let alone how they are to be addressed. This is something I had not had much exposure to, while in school, before this lecture and the past assignment. I think the more we are able to learn from, the more I personally will be comfortable in caring for this patients just because I actually can be aware of what they are going through. I was surprised by how much of an impact all of the hardships the LGBTQQA individuals experience has on their overall healthcare. This is even more motivation as an accessible healthcare provider to be accepting of all people and focus on not judging them but rather doing what we can to give them the resources and care they need. The video from the NY health department was also eye-opening since I had never realized how the way someone identifies could interfere with the healthcare they receive. I could not imagine not providing proper care for someone based on this, and that is why it is so important we educate ourselves as to not be uncomfortable but rather can provide better care with these patients. I think it would be helpful if we received more proper education throughout our curriculum on different drug regimens we will be seeing for these patients and I know it would be of benefit for everyone to have exposure to this.
ReplyDeleteI understand the importance of learning and continuing to learn about health disparities and differences this patient population faces, however I feel comfortable with this group. Listening in lecture, I kept thinking that the key was being respectful and always asking open-ended questions which is what COPHS emphasizes from the beginning of the pharmacy program. Making assumptions about any patient can be detrimental to their care, and all patients have a right to be respected like any other human being. So even though learning about trends and issues in the LGBTQQA community is important to their care, I see this just like learning about any other disease state or racial/ethnic group. The difference seems to be how the medical community has historically treated this group, as was shown in the NY Public Health Department video.
ReplyDeleteWhen put into perspective, I was shocked to hear about how few hours of LGBTQQA medical and pharmacy students receive as part of their curriculum. Pharmacy is a career path that encourages empathy with patients to help them feel more empowered to manage their health. Pharmacists should have more training about the barriers LGBTQQA patients face when receiving health care. I personally felt uninformed about those barriers until discussing them during our class. The therapies these patients are on can cause lifetime side effects and that is something pharmacists need to be educated on. Moreover, understanding how our patients prefer to be addressed is important in order to be respectful and provide a comfortable and open environment. When patients do not feel comfortable, they will delay receiving proper health care which can have detrimental long term effects. In the New York Public Health Department video, there was a transgender man that spoke about being denied health care when he was diagnosed with breast cancer. It breaks my heart knowing that anyone felt like he is not deserving of the same respect and well-being as anyone else. Health care providers need to be accepting of all patients, as a vital part of the field is empathy. This is particularly important in rural settings or small communities because the probability of personally knowing many of your patients, or your patients knowing each other, is fairly high. I wish we had the opportunity to learn more about working with this patient group in order to help them receive the care they deserve.
ReplyDeleteIn July of 2016, Walgreens joined forces with the Human Rights Campaign (HRC) to ensure that LGBTQ Patients are being respected in the pharmacy. They distributed a resource guide to all of Walgreens healthcare professionals across the country that helps them to identify terminology and identities, as well as the health disparities of the LGBTQ community. What a great idea! The guide also provides pharmacy specific information on transition-related services for transgender people seeking hormone replacement therapy and on HIV prevention and care.
ReplyDeleteI think that more pharmacy chains need to implement programs like this. LGBTQQA patients have their own healthcare needs and we need to be knowledgeable about them. Since we aren't taught much about them in school, we need to make sure we have the resources as healthcare professionals to provide the best care for these patients, just as we do for all other patients.
Read more about the program here: http://www.hrc.org/blog/hrc-walgreens-join-forces-to-ensure-respectful-treatment-of-lgbtq-patie
The resource guide is available here: http://www.hrc.org/resources/providing-lgbtq-inclusive-care-and-services-at-your-pharmacy
DeleteI reviewed this document - it is very well done. When in the curriculum should it be introduced? 2nd semester of P3 seems a little late. Would it be something that could go with patient communication in P1 Pharmaceutics/lab. Or do you think the P1s aren't mature enough to think this through? Could it be developed into a case presentation for Therapeutics?
DeleteI think it was a great point that was made in class about how in Butler's pharmacy program we don't even have 1 hour of therapeutics lectures about treatment in the LGBTQ community. This is definitely an area that gets neglected by the healthcare professional community, but it is one that is so crucial that we understand.
ReplyDeleteEmpathy and the willingness to accept and feel comfortable addressing healthcare concerns with members of the LGBTQ community is something that is so crucial to our profession. The most important part of caring for this (and ANY) patient population is simply showing respect and care for our patients and making their experience as individualized as possible. It is important that we develop a rapport and environment of trust with our patients and respond to them in a way we would want to be treated ourselves.
I also think that although I come from a small town and now live in a city that I don't feel any different towards members of the LGBTQ community than I previously did. They are still patients and human beings and deserve the same treatment as all our other patients. I know I never want to compromise a patient's care based on their preferences or background and I would never want my patients to feel that I was judging them or prejudiced against them.
I do also feel like I learned some valuable points from the video we watched in class intended for medical students. I had never thought about calling a patient by their birth name when they prefer another name and how this might make someone feel. I have also never really thought about asking a patient what their preferred pronouns are in order to make them feel more comfortable and honor how they identify, rather than just making assumptions based on societal gender roles.
I believe that the ultimate goal of helping our patients to make sure they are getting the best care possible - that can only happen if we are treating each and every person with the respect they deserve.
ReplyDeleteOne fear I do have though, is whether or not my use of pronouns is offensive. I have listened to podcasts before that have had guests who identify as transgender, and it seems that there are some that are more understanding of situations in which you mistakenly use the wrong pronoun and there are some that are offended if you do not know their preferred pronouns. I guess I want to have more clarification on if it is acceptable to ask, "what pronouns do you prefer?"
Like Rachel, I think it was a very interesting point to think about the amount of time we spend on LGBTQ as a topic. It is hard to know much about the issues affecting this population when it is thrown in the shuffle of all the other topics of therapeutics. I hope that in the future we are introducing more about these topics as the population becomes more an more prominent in communities.
I thought our LGBT class was extremely beneficial. It is a topic we spend very little time on. It is something that people have a variety of feelings about, but at the end of the day we need to be as professional as possible. Many of these people are likely bullied or put down in other aspects of their lives. We should be someone they can trust, not another raised eyebrow or weird smirk.
ReplyDeleteAt the pharmacy I work at, we have a patient who is transgender. He is a teenager. And when you type in their name to the computer system (female name still), a note bubble pops up stating to use male pronouns such as he and him. I am more comfortable now that I have interacted a few times with him. I think it takes time to grow more comfortable, but I also thought I hadn't been trained to know how to handle the situation. our LGBT class reminded me to just treat these individuals as any patient. Ask more questions when needed and keep all judgement aside. We are here to help them with their health. I also had no idea that many lesbian women did not seek healthcare as much as other women. I think that needs to change. No one should be afraid to seek care.
I think the LGBT lecture was something that needed to be talked about during my time in the pharmacy program. Especially in the world today where more people in this group are finding a voice and showing courage to make the world know that they exist. Growing up with a Catholic education, I was always taught that being gay, bi, ect ect was a sin, but I also was taught that you were to show kindness to everyone no matter the differences between you and them. I will admit that at times I may feel uncomfortable when it comes to interacting with people of the group, but from continuing to serve them at the pharmacy I work at and treating them like normal human beings, you can feel their gratitude by not judging them like so many other people might. One of my stores patients is a transgender who works at our store. I remember a few days after our pharmacy had gotten robbed, a event that normally does not occur at our location, our patient was so concerned for all the people that work at our pharmacy because she knew that one of us could have been harmed. She ended up making dessert for the pharmacy and writing us a note talking about how she was so glad that we were all ok. This meant a lot because it showed that by treating her with respect, we became someone she deeply care about. Never judge a book by its cover because you don't know what other people are experiencing in their own lives.
ReplyDeleteIn my high school an upper classman was transgender. As a freshman in high school I was startled to see this, but as I got to know this person, I realized that how they identified themselves did not change how they lived or treated others. I also had a classmate who was gay and many people bullied her and treated her poorly. I always felt bad for her because she was such a nice person and never deserved any of the hate she got because of her sexuality. This girl eventually went on to become a famous Youtube star. Her and her partner recently decided to have a child, and she wanted to be the carrier of the baby. This news was not received well by many people on the internet, but she has remained positive throughout her pregnancy experience. She is such a strong individual who I have immense respect for. Here is a recent article about her story:
ReplyDeletehttps://www.buzzfeed.com/skarlan/dance-off-the-haters?utm_term=.pvKN2bDKxj#.nyXe4N9roX
Although I have been exposed to this topic earlier in my life, I thought this class was very helpful and helped me even further to understand what the LGBTQQA community goes through. It is something that every healthcare professional should learn about at some point in their curriculum. As future healthcare professionals I believe it is important to become advocates for this community and be sure that our coworkers and peers are informed and accepting.
I was really excited to see us cover this, especially knowing that we were going to be covering the trans patient population. I definitely don't think we cover it enough, espcially seeing as how much the LGBTQ+ community needs us. We might be the only professional they can trust or can get to.
ReplyDeleteI've mentioned before I think, but I'm current secretary of Butler Alliance, Butler's LGBTQ+ and allies group on campus. This community, particularly the trans community, is one I care very much for and I dedicate most of my time to it. It's my community after all!
I actually have office hours every week on Mondays 9-noon if anyone has any questions or wants to talk (and I'm in more often than that). Our office is in the basement of the Atherton Union, in the Effromyson Diversity Center. You're welcome to catch me after class if you have trouble locating it, or you or anyone else with questions can email me as well.
I really loved the video. I think it did a good job with the topics and emphasizing the need for empathy. That really is the most important thing. If you ever have any doubts, my advice is to say 'is this how I treat heteosexual and cisgender people? Is this how I want to be treated? Is this anything I need to know?'
Everyone has prejudice. We're hardwired with it. But making the effort is what matters. Try to learn and be better every day. Even members of the LGBTQ+ community have these problems. It can be against other members or internalized. Don't feel bad about not knowing or having the thoughts. Good people aren't people who never make mistakes or have bad thoughts, they're people who make mistakes and strive to do better or have bad thoughts and wok to remind themselves why those thoughts aren't good.
As for medical professionals, it's our job to recognize that we as the medical community have a long history of abuse with these groups and others. Recognize, empathize. Realize where these people come from and know it's justified, and make a commitment to do better than those who came before us! Ask what they need, what would make them comfortable, what issues they have with things.
I grew up in a small town and wow is the attitude and community different. There's obviously still problems here.
One thing I'd like to point out is a startling discrepancy for lifespans of the LGBTQ+ community. The average life expectancy in the US for men and women is between 75-80 years old. For trans people (particularly trans women, and ESPECIALLY trans women of color) the average life expectancy is less than 35. This is due to high rates of murder and suicide, but might also be due to not receiving proper medical care. (I wasn't able to find any good sources for gay men, lesbians, or bisexuals, so I'll look that up again later). That number should be shocking and is completely unacceptable).
I'd like to talk about some things that I think would really help if you want to be a good provider and friend for the LGBTQ+ people in your life. I'll put them in a reply to this comment!
First, there are lots of correct ways to list the acronym! I use LGBTQ+ because I get tongue tied and the plus signifies the inclusion of other letters. It's mostly about recognizing that it's more than 4. LGBTQ and LGBTQA+ are also common. Alliance is officially listed as GLBT because its the older acronym and the original grant we received came with the request that it be put like that. There's lots of ways to describe it and even the members of the community do it differently.
DeleteAlso please don't ever refer to the A as standing for allies. You will get a very plastic smile at best. It's for agender and asexual.
Queer is something you shouldn't use if you do not identify as queer. Also, there are many people who do not like the word in the community because it's been used against them and they find no power in reclaiming it. Some also don't think it should be used at all, but queer has heavy use in the bisexual, pansexual, transgender, and PoC community and most people who have problems with it are often white, cis, and lesbian or gay exclusively (and there is a heavy history of biphobia, racism, and transphobia in this community like in every community). The younger community seems to like it a bit more. The general rule of thumb? If it's not your word don't use it. Don't use it for anyone without their consent.
This also goes for transs*xual. I've heard one instance where a trans person used that word for themselves. Everyone else will grimace and probably avoid you if you use it. If you want to indicate someone using medical science to transition, just say they're transitioning. Are they getting surgery? Surgical transition! Hormones? Hormonal transition! Medically transitioning can be used for either or both. Someone is the same gender before and after they medically transition, or if they do at all. That's why transs*xual is generally not a word to use unless you know the individual uses it. Its more common in older members of the community. Young'uns don't tend to like it.
Words like queer, transs*xual, f*g, and d*ke are not things you should use if you would not use it for yourself and if they aren't works used to dehumanize YOUR specific group. D*ke is a word used against lesbians (it can be used to address someone who is not a lesbian, but the insinuation is that the subject is a lesbian and is therefore less, it implies lesbian is an insult, lesbian isn't an insult) therefore those who aren't lesbians shouldn't use it. A woman of any sexuality including straight and bi can be called a d*ke, but it's not your word to reclaim. And many lesbians do not like the word even reclaimed.
Also 'transgendered'? Not a thing. Trans is something you are, not something that happens to you. No 'ed'. Also, never say 'a trans'. Someone is a transwoman, a transman, a trans person, but they are not 'a trans'. Trans is an adjective, not a noun. A tall guy. A brown-haired guy. A trans guy. Not a tall, a brown-haired, a trans.
As for other terms, DFAB/AFAB and DMAB/AMAB are good terms to know. Described/decided or assigned female at birth describes someone with a vagina and uterus. Described/decided or assigned male at birth describes someone with an penis and testes.
PRONOUNS. Ask! Always ask! Trans people love being asked. Use it as basic introductory like you do with names! 'Hi! It's nice to meet you! What's your name? What's your pronouns?' And give yours back! 'I'm __ the pharmacist! My pronouns are __/__ or I use __/__' There's actually been a movement to start putting it on resumes and nametags with names. Did they tell you before and you forgot? Ask again, like you would with a name. 'Okay, one more time, what pronouns do you use' They would rather you ask than misgender them.
DeleteOn the topic of misgendering, what do you do if you do slip up? Correct yourself, but don't dwell, make a scene, or make it about you. 'Yeah so she said- oh sorry he - he said that...' is good. Fix and go. Don't 'oh my god I'm so sorry this usually never happens you know I try to be a good ally I just get so mixed up it's so hard to remember, please don't be mad' No one needs that or has time for it. Also, if you misgender someone (or deadname them) and do not correct or apologize they will probably never come back. Never. I've had I don't know how many people text the group chat asking for new doctors/dentists/pharmacists/therapists/advisers because someone refused to acknowledge their gender. They won't be back and they will tell everyone else to not come to you either.
Does this sound extreme? What if someone refused to call you by your name? Every time. You've told them your name and your major or something, but no matter what they will call you something different. Every time. That isn't your name. And imagine it every day every hour for however long you've been alive. You'd think the person didn't care about you at all either. You'd want a different friend, different doctor, different parent. Now imagine that came with people not treating you like a person. Some people get crabby. Try to understand where they come from. Empathy.
Not know? ASK.
Also, don't ask invasive questions. Do YOU want someone to ask about your genitals when that's not their business?
Talk to them like a person. 'Hey, I just want you to know that I do care for you as my patient. I want you to know that if I mess up or make you uncomfortable, or if there's something you want to discuss, I'll listen.' A correction isn't a personal attack against you, it's them trying to reach you, person to person, so that you relationship can be meaningful and positive.
And if you do things right? You'll have their loyalty. They'll listen, come back, tell all their friends. You will have made a difference in the life of someone that needs you. So many LGBTQ+ people have been abused by their care providers, been treated like they don't matter. They're terrified to seek help. Do you know how many suicidal people I've sat with, who knew they needed help but were terrified of psychologists, pharmacists, ER doctors, disability specialists? Too many. A fellow student with a pair of scuffed up boots and caffeine habit should not have to be the closest they can manage to get to medical help. You have the ability to be their lifeline. You have the ability to be the most positive, validating person they encounter today. And all it takes is treating them like a person.
ReplyDeleteUnfortunately, I guess I had never thought about the extent of the health disparities that exist for the LGBTQ community. Now that I am more familiar with the discrimination they receive in the medical world, I definitely agree that pharmacy schools and medical schools should spend more curriculum time on these issues. Considering that pharmacists are one of the most accessible healthcare professionals, we have the opportunity to create a unique relationship with patients.
I have a friend from home who struggles telling her parents about her sexual orientation, and I have interacted with LGBTQ patients that come to the pharmacy I work at. However, this does not make me an expert, and I always want to find the right way to show respect. I think this lecture was very beneficial and the resources will be great tools to further my knowledge.
I think it was a good discussion to have because as others have pointed out we do not have a lot of curriculum time devoted to the topic. As healthcare professionals I think it is our responsibility to know how to care for these patients and interact with them appropriately. This population should be comfortable coming to us with health care concerns and questions without fear of judgement or discrimination.
ReplyDeleteAt the pharmacy I work at, we have one transgender patient that I know of. She is very polite and she has built up a great relationship with both of our pharmacists and many of the technicians. I think she is in a place where she trusts us as a pharmacy. Someone brought up pronouns as very important to this group of people. I remember one day where this particular patient came to pick up a prescription and I was at the register. It was not quite ready and just needed to be verified by the pharmacist. The pharmacist said “It’s almost ready” to me and the patient. She thought the pharmacist said “his” is almost ready and she was very quick to correct him to the right pronoun. The pharmacist was very confused because he had said “it” as in the prescription, but she was very polite in explaining what she thought was said and what she preferred. I thought this was a good example of the importance of pronouns for these patients and how it can make a difference in their comfort level. She still uses our pharmacy on a regular basis and I think her relationship with the staff is very helpful.
I really thought our discussion last Wednesday was beneficial and necessary for us as pharmacy students. The closing statement made to the class really stuck with me as well: no matter your religious beliefs, every person/patient deserves to be treated with respect and with the same, equal care. No one should be looked down upon for being who they are. A transgender patient in the video described his awful experience with his doctor when he was diagnosed with breast cancer. The doctor immediately told the patient he disagreed with his decision to transition, and that his first thought was to refer the patient to psychiatry. This was shocking and sad to hear.
ReplyDeleteI've never worked with a transgender patient as a pharmacy intern, but the video shown in class coupled with class discussion has now prepared me for such interaction.
The video should be shown to all medical professions to ensure that this community is treated with the finest care.
I felt that the LGBT discussion we had in class was very informational. Like we discussed, we do not get a whole lot of information on the topic in our regular curriculum. I feel that I am much better informed now than I was before class. I did not realize the wide variety of identifications that a person could have. There were some I had never heard of before.
ReplyDeleteLike most, I did not give much thought to the different health disparities that a LGBT patient may experience. Regardless, I agree that showing compassion is key when treating any patient, LGBT patients included.
Off the top of my head, I can't think of any of my patients from work who are LGBT, but that doesn't mean that there aren't any. The likelihood that I would have an LGBT patient is much higher in Indianapolis than it would be back in my home town. My home town is predominantly white and republican.
I think that as healthcare professionals it is important to take care of the patient, regardless of our own personal beliefs versus theirs. It was heartbreaking to hear the stories people had from when they had been turned away or judged by practitioners just because of how they identified.
The class focused on this issue was very beneficial. There is not really another place in our curriculum where we have discussed this topic. I think it is very unprofessional and a sad reflection on our society that people in this group receive substandard care or are refused service simply because of who they are. I feel like I am comfortable around people who identify with the LGBTQA group, but I am not as comfortable with their specific needs medically. I think it is very important to make LGBTQA patients comfortable to avoid any interruptions in their care. I think educating the public about is a key to acceptance. People tend to be afraid of what they don't know, so people who are different them may cause them anxiety and give off the impression of disdain. I think we all just need to get to know people for who they are and not what we classify them as.
ReplyDeleteWe have had a couple of LGBT clients at my pharmacy over the past year, and they understand how in our system our knee-jerk reaction sometimes is to go by their birth name due to insurance purposes. But we take care to note that patient’s preferred name and strive to call them by that. But we are human and make mistakes. And if these patients were back in my hometown, the reaction would be VERY different. I am from small-town Indiana where many people have either never interacted with an LGBT person or have set beliefs on the topic which can either be negative or positive.
ReplyDeleteMy stance has always been the same, whether you are LGBT, black, white, purple, or other, I will treat you with respect and dignity so long as you do the same for me. It is an important value to respect others and things they believe in. However, there is definitely a disconnect between the lines of respect and acceptance that happens on both sides of this particular topic. It is very difficult to talk out things with others who automatically call you a bigot just because you don’t believe or fight for what they believe. I respect everyone’s freedom of choice. I respect everyone’s differences. But I too have the freedom to believe in what I do. And with my beliefs, I will provide the best service to everyone and learn about any specific disease state or medication that is required to help my patient get the best healthcare they deserve.
To begin, I would like to thank everyone, especially Dr. VanTyle for keeping an open mind and being respectful toward this subject, as it can be very uncomfortable and controversial at times for some individuals. Personally, I come from a small, rural hometown, in which people are judged constantly if they do not fit into a specific stereotype or act in a certain way. With that being said, individuals who choose to be a part of the LGTBQA community tend to be excluded and reprimanded for the decisions they have made in this particular town.
ReplyDeleteMoving to a large city has opened my eyes to many walks of life, in which I have overcame the stereotype that was instilled in me during my upbringing and have learned to appreciate each and every individual. By being exposed to members of the LGTBQA, I will be able to serve their specific needs as a pharmacist in the most respectful manner I possibly can. As my mother has always said, "You never know what someone is experiencing unless you put yourself in their shoes." Even though I have lived by this saying for my entire life, it will continue to guide me in a positive manner throughout both my personal and professional phase of life.
I believe that this is a very important topic to talk about as a future healthcare professional. Whether we agree or disagree, all patients are people and should be treated with the same compassion and respect. Although it may be difficult for some providers, I believe that it is never okay to turn people away because of their sexual preference or identification. However, something that I had never really thought of was asking patients how they prefer to be addressed. It is something that is so simple but also something that was never taught to us in class. I, personally, do not feel completely comfortable, as I believe that we have not really learned much about LGBTQQA individuals in classes. I think that it is a topic that most definitely needs to be better worked into the curriculum. I do believe, though, that I will always be learning and the more I practice and encounter these individuals, the more confident and comfortable I will become with having a better idea of what they are going through.
ReplyDeleteI thought that the video from the NY health department was very interesting in that I have never dealt with this patient population and was unaware of the struggles that they encounter while trying to receive healthcare. I think that this video could be an essential tool in teaching healthcare professionals how to properly care for this patient population.